In this question, I included a lot of detail that turned out to be unnecessary and misguided.

The first responder helped me realize that I was over-thinking the problem, and I accepted his answer.

I think the question might have value for others, but only if I completely rewrite it without all the extra garbage I included originally. The edits would amount to essentially a complete rewrite and might make the responses appear out of context.

Is it acceptable to totally overhaul a question after accepting an answer?

Note: I found a possible duplicate after posting, although my issue is more about fixing a question vs. improving it. I'm open to deleting this question if appropriate.


I've had this happen to me on occasion.

I feel comfortable with making small edits to my posts, correcting errors, etc. that don't completely change the meaning, without indicating that I changed anything. That's what the revision history is for, after all.

But when I have to totally overhaul the post, I try to strike the text here's a really long and off-topic sentence or something that nobody really needs to read in order to not mislead later readers. (Why the heck did this answer get 4 upvotes? What an idiot!!! -1 -1 -1). Yes, anybody can see the revision history, but sometimes it's nice to just have a visual cue that some substantial editing has taken place.

  • Thanks to both responders - found both answers equally helpful. Would have accepted both if it were possible. Thanks again. – cantera25 Nov 30 '11 at 20:16

If your edits change the question so much that it is basically a different question and its answers are no longer applicable, leave the question alone. Walk away.

If you can add clarity to a question, do so. If the question itself is fundamentally the same, the answers fit, then by all means, make the question better.

From your description, it appears your question and answers served a good purpose. You were overthinking the problem, the answer brought that to your attention. In my mind, that has value. Someone else may in fact overthink the same problem.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .