This user has serial up-voting reversed, but he still have badge Mortarboard.
Is it correct behavior of badges? I suppose it should be reversed too.
And will this 200 daily reputation (2012-03-20) score for the Epic, and Legendary badges?
Meta Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for meta-discussion of the Stack Exchange family of Q&A websites. It only takes a minute to sign up.Sign up to join this community
As a matter of policy, awarded badges do not get reversed.
The only exception to this rule is fraud. If we are made aware of badges that were awarded fraudulently (sock puppetry, maliciously-intended voting irregularity or other), they will be revoked.
Badges are never removed, with the exception of tag badges; in that case, the badge is removed when the score for that tag is not the required one, or the number of questions for which you posted answer is not the required one. (See the .htaccess silver badge as example.)
If the badge can be gained more than once, and the requirements for getting it are not satisfied anymore, the badge is not removed, but the next time that badge would be given, a new badge is not added.