Say you're looking over the new questions, looking for a chance to solve someone's problem, and you see a question which is absolutely, unquestionably off-topic, or is much too localized, and it gets closed.

But you have the answer.

Should you share it anyway?

I do realize this is really a matter of personal choice, but I want to know what the community's general stance is.

  • a) Preferably not. b) How do you propose to do that? Closure prevents posting an answer. Via a comment? – Josh Caswell Jul 28 '12 at 8:04
  • I'd rather 1) write a new question based on whatever useful bits were there in the original one and 2) self-answer it. Then, I'd 3) post a comment in that "original" question, referring to a new one - to establish a link and let OP and other readers see my answer posted in a new question – gnat Jul 28 '12 at 12:05

You can post it as a comment, and the asker will be notified.

Comments are generally softer than answers, so I don't think you're going to get ratted on for it. At best, the user gets the answer they want, and you've helped somebody; at worst, the question gets deleted, taking the comment with it.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .