26

Locked questions get unhelpful messages like this:

enter image description here

My problem with this is that it implies that if I go to meta, I'll get more information about why that specific question is locked, perhaps finding a discussion of its merits. However, the link just sends me to the main meta page, where I eventually realize there's nothing specific to the question.

Can we improve this situation?

Here are some suggestions (roughly in descending order of preference):

  • make the link point to an actual discussion, on meta, of that question

  • make the link point to the site-specific FAQ, specifically the portion that covers what is/is not acceptable content

  • make the link point to some discussion/documentation of what happens when a question is locked, and how the process is resolved/closed

  • change the wording of the message so it doesn't imply that there is any specifically relevant discussion on meta

  • remove "For more info visit meta" bit altogether

13
+50

I like:

  • make the link point to an actual discussion, on meta, of that question

Perhaps that can happen automatically. There is already a list of "linked posts" maintained automatically. This is "just" a cross-site linked posts feature, shown in a different place. For most sites this is likely to be between the per-site meta and main, not the broader problem.

If a meta question really is discussing a question on the main site then it ought to have a link of one form or another in it. This could happen for any question being discussed on the per site meta somewhere - users will learn about meta and be generally more informed about site/question issues.

For the case of SO and MSO which is not a site specific meta this might be a bit more complicated to manage, but last I saw SO was supposed to get its own proper meta soon.

Linking like this would be useful for small beta sites (we're defining our policies/topic right now) and large sites (this is being discussed further).

4

Interesting idea. I'd like to see a combination of your suggestions implemented, where the word "locked" is a link, and links to the explanation of locking, and the "visit meta" is a link to a meta post specifically about that locked question.

Of course, this would require that a meta post be created for it. I think it would be a good idea to either automatically create one when a question is locked, or allow the locking moderator to link to an existing one. Since "disputes about its content are being resolved", there will inevitably be a meta discussion anyway (or there at least should be), so pointing people to it will be useful.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .