I noticed the new community eval queue on Chem. I like the concept, but I feel that is should allow for separate voting for the Q and As:
Currently, the categories talk of the combined quality of the Q & A (Well, all except Satisfactory which seems to talk about answers only). Most of the time, I've come across OK-ish questions with good answers (or a good collective answer pool), and sometimes vice versa. It's pretty hard to vote for these. Giving another set of voting buttons for the collective answer pool may make this more intuitive (as well as helping pinpoint which part of the site needs improvement)
Also, can we have eval-specific comments? In our evaluation, I found the comments much more helpful than the vote counts. Yes, I know the data is tabulated in the end, but we could add a link to a list of anonymized eval-comments per post. Even better, make the list public -- the old evals didn't have any privacy regarding comments, and that was a good thing.
Just an afterthought: In the mod interface, an extra column "Net score" would be nice (Each "Excellent" is +1, "Satisfactory" is 0, "Needs Improvement" is -1).. The current "total" column just shows how many people voted.