4

Possible Duplicate:
Comment links on review page lead to nowhere, when they exist

Sample review item with a couple comments: https://english.stackexchange.com/review/close/13016.

The comment links are all of the form

<site>/review/close/<current review item ID>#<comment ID> 

Clicking on any of them takes me to a different review item from the queue. I would have expected them to be of the form

<site>/questions/<question ID>/#<comment ID> 

which would actually take me to the corresponding comment so I can upvote it or fix the formatting (I can't do either in the review queue).

  • Well, the anchor has href="#<comment ID>" so the link is relative to the current page. – Shadow Keeps Social Distance Nov 20 '12 at 10:36
  • 1
    @Sha yes, and it shouldn't be. Neither should a link relative to the current page load a different page. That's not really relative to the current page, like, at all. – ЯegDwight Nov 20 '12 at 10:44

Browse other questions tagged .