There are a number of times where a user will erroneously post what should be an edit on an answer.

A number of those times, there are other users that will still follow up the entire question on the answer that should have been an edit to the original post.

Currently, the "convert to edit" tool only converts the answer to an edit. It blows away all the comments on the answer.

There is a workaround, but it's very ugly and cumbersome:

  • Click on the answer to go to the page, taking me out of the moderator queue (which no operation should ever make me do). If I convert to an edit, or convert the answer to a comment on the question, I've lost the flag and the answer, so I have to be on the page.
  • Convert the answer to an edit.
  • Undelete the answer.
  • Convert the answer to a comment, moving all the comments on it.
  • Delete the comment that was the original answer in the comments on the question.

A checkbox that would allow me to move all the comments on the answer along with the edit reduce the above steps to a single step.

  • Since I just asked the same question I guess I second that feature request ;)
    – Gordon
    Jul 27, 2013 at 9:15
  • It's clear that the "convert to edit" feature was not well thought out before implementation, and that fixing it is a very low priority, since it affects only a tiny number of users. I, too, run across this problem regularly.
    – Dave Tweed
    Oct 9, 2016 at 10:50


You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .