6

I've been running a publicist badge experiment lately.

I think it is safe to say that there is a strong benefit to sharing most of the questions.

However, is it worthwhile to reward users for sharing gimmicky closed questions like "What's your favorite programmer cartoon?"

Is there a net benefit to the site, or does it bring people to the site in the wrong way?

I think the answer is: probably not worth it. They probably shouldn't count towards sharing badges. As it stands, there is an incentive to share such questions because they are indeed very interesting to many.

Edit

  • There may be another category of questions that shouldn't apply, such as some locked questions. What is your best programmer joke?
  • This experiment involved rapidly sharing questions on relevant subreddits and hacker news. This lasted about 9 days and was enough to generate some backlash from reddit. I do not recommend sharing questions in this matter, especially over a prolonged period, as it can impact other communities' views of SO in a negative way.

You must log in to answer this question.