9

The Possible duplicate auto-comment is pretty bare bones right now; just "Possible duplicate of [title of duplicate as link]".

I've noticed since we can now only close questions as duplicates of answered questions, we can make the comment a bit friendlier; it's not just a dupe (sadface), it has my answers (happyface!). Waxeagle suggested something similar to this, a comment of his own. Here's another possible wording:

This question appears to be a duplicate of [link] which already has [n] answers; see if you can find your answer there or edit your question to clarify why those answers do not suit your situation.

The edit bit is something extra I often throw in when I'm only 90% sure a post is a dupe, to see if I can goad more details out of the asker.

There's also two edge cases that allow dupe close votes without the souce question being answered; should probably still get the old comment form. These cases are MSO questions (any question can be voted as a dupe without answers) and where the dupe is also posted by the same user. In fact in that second case the auto comment could be something like:

This question appears to cover the same ground as your earlier question [link]. There's no need to repost, if you need to update your earlier question simply [edit it] (link to edit original Q).

  • I'm wax eagle and I endorse this feature request. – wax eagle Mar 15 '13 at 15:40
  • 6
    Whoa now, "Possible duplicate"? I think you mean "possible duplicate"; it'll be a cold day in hell before SE starts capitalizing that comment – Michael Mrozek Mar 15 '13 at 15:44
  • @MichaelMrozek Well the new one's a full sentence, so they no longer have a reason to not capitalize it. – Ben Brocka Mar 15 '13 at 16:03
5

The OP actually gets a huge in-your-face box at the very top as soon as a close-as-dupe vote is cast:

enter image description here

– you just don't see it, since it's only shown to the question owner.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .