5

The requirements text seems to carry different meanings in different places for the tag badges. I shall use the gold tag badges as an example

Gold badges page
The text explaining the requirements for the tag badges appears to be inconsistent. For example here on the gold badges page the requirement for the gold tag badge is:

You must have a total score of 1000 in at least 200 non-community wiki answers to achieve this badge.

A score of 1000 could imply 100 upvotes (at a score of 10 a piece, possibly with adjustment for downvotes).


Specific badge page
On the other hand the badge itself says:

Earned 1000 upvotes for at least 200 answers in the ??? tag


I realise that score is a somewhat ambiguous term but I expect others will share my score=reputation assumption. It is at the very least ambiguous at present.

Even if we assume score=votes (which having looked carefully is clearly the case) then they remain subtly different as the first includes downvotes whereas the second interpretation doesn't.

3
  • I realise bug may be a little bit of an extreme tag to give this, but of the 4 required tags it seemed the closest fit – Richard Tingle Jun 27 '13 at 13:49
  • I would say discussion would be a better fit... – m0sa Jul 4 '13 at 12:39
  • @m0sa I suppose it is a discussion as to whether this is in fact wrong or if my interpretation is wrong – Richard Tingle Jul 4 '13 at 12:42
3

The FAQ on badges states clearly:

The term score means the total number of upvotes minus the total number of downvotes.

So there's no problem with the gold badge page, but the page that says "1000 upvotes" should be fixed. I believe someone with 1000 upvotes precisely, and non zero downvotes, or 1001 upvotes and 1 or more downvotes (etc) would not get the badge.

2
  • Excellent, I didn't want to come down heavily on one text vs the other (although possibly the definition of score should be on the badges page itself), just that the two definitions couldn't both simultaneously be true – Richard Tingle Jul 4 '13 at 13:03
  • This fix now appears to have been implemented – Richard Tingle Aug 12 '13 at 12:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .