When reviewing a low quality post. The whole point of the review is to maintain high standard of the site. There is a gap between answers that should be deleted or just improved bit.
I can see this is not a first time user. The question has no accepted answer and was only posted today. I left a comment to the user to improve the answer, as I believe, if the answer is expanded it could become useful. I understand what the user is saying, but the user has put little effort into it or that the answer could do with some more effort.
Currently the options are:
- Looks Good
- Edit
- Recommend Deletion
- Skip
Yes I can leave a comment, but that is not guaranteeing that the post is improved.
My feature suggestion is:
I wish there was an option, eg issue for deletion if not improved. Set to a timer, if substantial edits are not made; ie >20 chars and the edited post could automatically go onto the review queue.
These post could be put on hold, like some questions are, so that there is a warning for the user and time for them to improve the post.
Edit
In this case, the comment resulted in a positive discussion and the post was improved.