Scenario 1: A case of confidentiality
An OP edited his question to replace specific project names with generic ones for confidentiality reasons†. After that, he suggested an edit to apply the same name changes to an answer posted by another user. Said suggested edit was subsequently rejected.
What is the right thing to do here regarding this suggested edit?
Just reject the suggested edit
- Reason(s) For:
- Suggested edit is minor if judged by itself
- Reason(s) Against:
- Names used in the answer would be inconsistent with the recently modified names in the question.
- Doesn't honor OP's wish to preserve confidentiality
Reject the suggested edit + rollback the name changes done by the OP in the question
- Reason(s) For:
- Suggested edit is minor if judged by itself
- It preserves the consistency of names in both question and answer(s).
- Reason(s) Against:
- Doesn't honor OP's wish to preserve confidentiality
Approve the suggested edit
- Reason(s) For:
- It honors the OP's wishes
- It preserves the consistency of names in both question and answer(s).
- Reason(s) Against:
- Judged by itself, the edit seems rather minor.
Scenario 2: A case of “bad” variable names
If your answer in Scenario 1 is to approve the edit, would you act differently if the reason for the name change is more trivial, e.g. the OP thought the original variable names used in the question were bad and changed them? See this other question and this edit suggested by the OP.
† As seen in the edit comment of his suggested edit.