6

I am wondering how I could have framed my question here better, or whether I have asked it in the wrong place, and if so where should I have asked it.

On a forum, I might have asked ... anyone using EF5 TPT on Windows XP if so how do you get it to work?

  • I take it the answer that was posted didn't help? – Robert Harvey Jul 31 '13 at 23:34
  • @KateGregory: Mash all that into an answer so I can upvote it. Include something about unreasonable expectations of hand-holding. :) – Robert Harvey Jul 31 '13 at 23:36
  • It has been flagged as duplicate, but I disagree that it is duplicate, since my question is about working on XP, and hence not Framework 4.5 – kirsten g Jul 31 '13 at 23:39
  • @RobertHarvey your wish is my command – Kate Gregory Jul 31 '13 at 23:42
  • I think the correct answer has been posted now. It will take a while for me to test it. – kirsten g Jul 31 '13 at 23:59
  • 1
    All (or at least most) of the additional information that was posted in a series of edits should have been there from the beginning. I'll publically admit to having downvoted the original version of your question when I saw it soon after posting, because it didn't contain nearly enough information to be answerable. I've since retracted that downvote because I believe it no longer applies. So you're going in the right direction! – Cody Gray Aug 1 '13 at 8:32
13

My first piece of advice is to get rid of all the [Update] business. Write a coherent question that makes sense to someone reading the whole thing for the first time. Put the actual question at the top.

I went to your question to edit it a little - some backticking around inline code, a blank line before a code block so that it would format properly - but I didn't get far. I did find a line that said vaguely "I get error messages" and later an [update] that said what they were, so I brought the error messages up to where you said you get them and deleted the [update]. But then I ran into trouble.

When you solve one problem but then something else happens, don't keep adding more and more story into your question. Leave the first one alone - for example, it was a duplicate of something, fine, let it be closed as that - and ask a fresh one. When you get that solved, accept the answer for that one and if you now have a third problem, ask that as a separate question. Updating the question as drastically as you are invalidates old answers and frustrates people.

We've talked about this on Meta before: take a look at Exit strategies for "chameleon questions" and Guidance To Avoid Chameleon Behavior and see if you recognize your behavior. It's a great sign that you have come here and asked for advice. This particular aspect of SO culture is a little unusual.

  • +1 for a lot of reasons, but especially, "It's a great sign that you have come here and asked for advice." – Jaydles Aug 1 '13 at 3:30

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .