I submitted a suggested edit, and when I checked the status later, I saw a message saying "This item is no longer reviewable", with no record of any reviews.

I searched meta for an answer, and found this: What can cause "This item is no longer reviewable"? However, the answer there doesn't seem to explain this. According to the answer, what happened in that case was that the edit suggestion was made to a previously edited post, and while the new suggestion was in the review queue, the revision it was based on was rolled back, invalidating the suggestion.

However, the post I edited, Lucene.net - How do I extract small snippets of texts from each match?, had no previous edits when I started editing, and as of this writing still hasn't been edited. I guessed that maybe an edit was made while I was editing, and was rolled back immediately, before there was even enough time for me to get the warning at the top that the post had been edited since I began. However, if that were the case, there should be a link to the edit history at the bottom of the post. Here's how it looks right now - note that the the area where that link should be, indicated by the FHRC, is blank:

enter image description here

Furthermore, I am not able to resubmit my edit. Figuring that regardless of what caused it to be designated "no longer reviewable", the edit is highly desirable (there was no language tag) and the post is still in its original state, so I resubmitted. Unfortunately, instead of being submitted as a new edit suggestion, it was treated as a modification to my original suggestion, which remains "no longer reviewable". There are no new suggestions in my activity log, and when I look at my original suggestion, I see that it has been modified to reflect a small difference in the resubmitted edit:

enter image description here

This is rather odd, since I've revised edit suggestions that were still under review before (the same way - by clicking the edit link in the post), and it always lets me edit starting from where I left off, but now if I edit, I start from the original post rather than from my my not yet approved edited version. Yes, when I view the post, I see the original, not an edited version that's viewable only to me until it's reviewed, as normally seen when one has an edit suggestion under review. But if that explains why I'm starting from the original version when I click edit, shouldn't it follow that this would be a new edit suggestion rather than a modification to the previous one?

Update 8/16/2013: Based on the feedback, I'm adding the bug tag. The bug to fix is that if an edit for some reason becomes unreviewable, subsequent edits from the same user should either be treated as new edit suggestions rather than modifying the original suggestion, or they should make the suggestion reviewable again.

Case in point, I still can't suggest an edit on that post, and the language tag still hasn't been added. I was going to ask if someone else could take care of that, but by this point it would be better to just wait until tomorrow and see if I can make the edit myself - it'll be interesting to see if my unreviewable edit suggestion will prevent me from editing the post after I cross 2,000 rep.

  • Well, you've got me stumped here. It couldn't be a grace period edit from the OP, because the suggestion was made 13 minutes after the question was asked. The timeline actually says review was invalidated 4 seconds before you suggested the edit (that really threw me off).
    – animuson StaffMod
    Aug 10, 2013 at 20:02
  • That’s not JavaScript; not even close! That’s C#. Lucene .NET. So, it’s weird, but we’re happy it didn’t go through :P
    – Ry-
    Aug 10, 2013 at 20:03
  • @minitech Ah, okay. I don't know c#. I thought javascript because he said "Java" in his description, but I saw the code speckled with var, which declares variables in javascript and not in Java. Out of curiosity, I tried to submit a new edit just now, adding the c# tag instead. The passage of time hasn't changed anything. It still started me from the original version of the post, but then modified my previous suggested edit to match the new one. And it's still in "not reviewable" limbo.
    – Adi Inbar
    Aug 10, 2013 at 20:29


You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .