2

I don't know how I got this idea, sorry if it is already asked. I searched but couldn't find. Let's say there is a question and X person writes first answer with low quality. Then Y person comes and writes a good answer. Then, X answer edits his own question containing the information Y shared, sometimes exactly with same words. Is it possible to detect this? If it happens what should we do?

marked as duplicate by Lix, hims056, Martijn Pieters, Lance Roberts, Aziz Shaikh Sep 26 '13 at 12:52

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • 3
    This will be more a problem, when the person X edit it within 5 minutes or so (so not showing as edited), and then when OP comes back, will more than possible to accept X's answer, as X has posted the answer first – Bolu Sep 26 '13 at 11:33
3

The proper response to this situation varies widely based on the circumstances and timing.

Your premised is based on the idea that "X" copied the answer from "Y" and added it to his post, But how do you know that happened? Word-for-word copying is obviously a good sign, but what if the wording isn't exact or isn't similar at all? How do you know that "Y" didn't arrive at the same idea that "X" did at the same time.

There is a phenomenon called Fastest Gun in the West (lovingly abbreviated FGITW) where users will post a quick answer to get in first, then add more to the answer as they go (often within the first 5 minutes so it doesn't even show up in the edit history).

But beyond that, users are known to post answers then realize they missed something or had another thought after hitting submit, and goes back to edit it in. They might not be aware of other answers that came in while they were typing.

This is where the timing of the events becomes important. If X and Y had answers at similar times or the "copied" info appears at a similar time, there is no way to know for certain that it was actually copied. It could have just been the aforementioned scenario. Now if hours have passed and this happens, then it is more likely.

In general, if you suspect someone copied your work, then you can flag, but keep in mind that multiple answers with the same/similar ideas and content are posted all of the time becasue there are only so many ways to accomplish a specific goal, especially for basic problems.

The other issue, as illustrated in the possible duplicate posts, is the CC-Wiki license of all content. I won't got into details since the possible duplicate already does a good job of explaining, but if the other user follows the attribution rules, then there is absolutely nothing wrong with it.

But most of all, regardless of what you decide to do with the post, following UV-D's advice, don't make a scene. That will just cause more issues and finger pointing, and then a mod will have to step in.

  • 3
    all this time (hic) I thought it was Fank God It's The Weekend – ljs.dev Sep 26 '13 at 11:44
1

If you notice this - flag this for moderator attention - under the category of 'other'. They will sort it out. But, do not make a scene about it.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .