15

Background

Within the voting tab of my profile any questions that I have voted to close which have then actually been closed are shown as deleted.

enter image description here

The related bug report has been marked I shall argue that it should be changed;

Proposal

I propose that any close vote that ultimately leads to a closure be marked "successful" rather than "deleted" as whatever the internal processes the end user will see it that way

Reasoning

From a users perspective their vote has not been deleted; it is still shown under the closed question as "closed by Voter1, Voter2 ...." as such the vote is "successful" not "deleted", from a users point of view a deleted vote would be one that aged away or was invalidated in some other way.

  • 4
    Even after I read that question many times whenever I see "deleted" under the vote, the first thought come in my mind is either my vote is removed or the question is deleted. It really needs to be changed. – hims056 Oct 29 '13 at 9:14
  • I agree that deleted is too vague. On the other hand, each question closed and not fixed is not really a success ;) – Mołot Oct 29 '13 at 9:48
4

I propose that the text displays the actual closure reason instead of simply saying "successful".

Thus there would be seven possible states:

  1. Active (if the vote is currently active)
  2. Expired (if the vote has aged away)
  3. Duplicate
  4. Off-Topic
  5. Unclear
  6. Too Broad
  7. Opinion Based

That way a user could review his or her close votes and see for what reason the question was closed actually.

  • Even better, the reason I propose just "successful" is because internally this is deleted so it would be a simple if (deleted){"successful"} but if this was easily implementable I'd favour this – Richard Tingle Oct 29 '13 at 9:29
  • 1
    Also "Active" if the vote is currently active and "Expired" if the vote is expired after 4 days. – hims056 Oct 29 '13 at 9:33
  • @hims056: Good suggestion. I edited my answer accordingly. – Spontifixus Oct 29 '13 at 10:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .