5

A while ago I failed a review audit because of the known problem that adding a comment to a highly upvoted post is being considered bad and that the answer is not completely correct.

Could you please remove the answer from the audit pool if it does not get corrected?

Also please do something with the problem that adding a comment to a highly upvoted post is being considered bad. Such unjustly failed audits discourage reviewers from voluntary help to Stack Exchange.

  • I have solved (I hope) the acute problem by down-voting the answer. It seems that a single down-vote will prevent the post from appearing in review audits: Review audit seems wrong – pabouk Nov 21 '13 at 9:27

Browse other questions tagged .