7

People make mistakes. We are humans - just like you, forgive us. I know it's been discussed here before, but I suggest a different approach.

Sometimes I up/down vote an answer because I believe it's right/wrong and the question asker should look/not look at it.

When someone posts an incorrect answer and gets voted up, some other user who detects this mistake will add a comment, explaining why this answer is not to be followed. Then I read that comment and understand that I have made a mistake as well following the answer and upvoting it (same goes for the opposite - down-voted correct answer).

My request - Include comments as a 'post edited' status - because sometimes even the original answerer posted a comment.

1
4

I'll agree with this simply as a more logical way to get my damn votes back whenever I make a mistake in voting. It doesn't seem logical to have to go and force an edit on a post just so I can retrieve the vote back.

1

This makes the vote lock almost useless, unless it lets you undo your vote only under ceratin conditions:

  • Doesn't count your own comments (the voter).
  • Only unlock if there's a new comment (after your vote) with enough upvotes (2 upvotes?)

I vote a lot, and I have made a few mistakes I couldn't undo, but I don't think it's important enough or happens often enough to change the system.

2
  • 3
    I didn't think that the threat of strategic downvoting was large enough to institute such a draconian lock in the first place, but they went ahead and changed it then. – TheTXI Sep 9 '09 at 12:17
  • "this makes the vote lock almost useless", which is a good thing. If i add a comment explaining why I am changing my mind, I should be able to unvote. – Michael Freidgeim Jul 24 '12 at 21:43

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .