0

In Stack Overflow review pages, when we closing or flagging a post a popup will appear something like:

Normal

When I drag that popup to extreme right, the page is showing a horizontal scroll bar:

With Horizontal scroll bar

If I scroll the page to left using that horizontal scroll bar the page shows white spaces:

Issue

Same issue happens when we place the popup to extreme bottom also:

Another issue

  • 3
    so don't move it there... – John Dvorak Dec 18 '13 at 20:12
  • @JanDvorak: I won't do that again :) But it won't fix that bug. – Midhun MP Dec 18 '13 at 20:30
  • 1
    It is not really a bug @MidhunMP ... That is just how dialogs work – qwertynl Dec 18 '13 at 20:39
  • @qwertynl: Thanks for the info dude, I wasn't aware of this. Thanks :) – Midhun MP Dec 18 '13 at 20:44
  • 3
    You report this as a bug, but don't tell us what the expected behavior should be? – Oded Dec 18 '13 at 20:55
  • @Oded: I expect that, there is no issue with left side or top side, so the similar should be for other two sides. – Midhun MP Dec 18 '13 at 20:57
6

A man goes to The Doctor one day and says:

My arm hurts when I do this

The Doctor responds:

So don't do that

The same applies here.

  • Why he said like that, instead of giving treatment/medicine ? :) If you say to him that you have pain in your teeth while chewing, what could be his answer ( not chew probably) ? :) – Midhun MP Dec 18 '13 at 20:26
  • The this implies some random movement that a person does not usually make :-P – qwertynl Dec 18 '13 at 20:27
  • Yeah. that's true :) but it won't fix the issue permanently :) – Midhun MP Dec 18 '13 at 20:31
1

"A man goes to The Doctor .. So don't do that"
The same answer could apply to all bugs.
"When I click upvote it doesn't work .. Well don't vote..".

But the point here is it's not a bug, nor status-by-design, it's the way the internet works and in fact this site handles that quite well I think.

The popup box when you click "flag" is site content, and it can be moved around. The fact it can be moved outside the standard site dimensions (X or Y) could return a few things:

  1. The box doesn't produce a horizontal or vertical scroll, as such you "lose" part of the content (the box) out of the site into no mans land and you cannot get to it fully. In fact you cannot get to it at all if you "throw" the flag box, thus needing the horizontal scroll to retrieve it.

  2. The box does produce a horizontal or vertical scroll, and as such you do not lose any part of what is actual site content as the site page dimensions grow with you moving the box.

When you think about it, 2. is more desirable by far, and more logical that actual site content changes the page dimensions as a part of the site. Rather than just disappearing as if it's suddenly not classed as site content.

In fact, if you are moving the box out of the way so you can access site content while deliberating over which flag to choose, then it changing the page dimensions is better still, as then you can move it right out of the way without losing it, and scroll to get it back if needed.

0

The area you describe as being empty actually contains the dialogue you just moved there. As such this seems like a case of a very well written page behaving exactly as it should under surprising circumstances. As such it very much isn't a bug

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .