6

I recently placed my first bounty on the following question (from someone else):

How to segment part of moving image based on details from fixed image in MATLAB?

hoping that a 100 rep reward (which, for MATLAB-tagged questions is roughly the equivalent to answering 10 questions) would attract some attention and maybe a good answer. But there are no new answers and the bounty period is over.

Is is because the question has been downvoted several times? I consider myself a novice on SO and I'd prefer not to throw my rep out of the window for no answers again.

Edit: can I (should I) migrate the question and the bounty to another SE site, such as the Signal Processing one, which is likely to be more suitable?

  • There could be any number of reasons, we can only really guess. Perhaps your question is too hard for most/all readers, perhaps it's not understandable, perhaps it's just not interesting, who knows. – Servy Jan 21 '14 at 21:14
  • 4
    Remember that a bounty is something that is meant to attract attention. It is absolutely not a guarantee that any new attention will draw out any answers. – Aaron Bertrand Jan 21 '14 at 21:45
  • @AlienArrays Disagree, all depends on the question. – Aaron Bertrand Jan 22 '14 at 2:52
11

There can be a number of reasons why a bounty does not attract an answer to an existing question. The question you linked already has what appears to be a pretty good answer on it. The question also seems fairly domain-specific, so maybe there aren't that many people frequenting Stack Overflow who know how to answer it well.

Sometimes the question itself is the problem. If it's not a high-quality question in the first place, it might not attract good answers anyway, despite the bounty.

You can help the question along by editing out the flotsam, like the "as a new user, I'm unable to attach more than two links," and the useless signature and "best regards."

Also, if you're expecting someone to hand you a complete, bug-free and documented solution from whole cloth, your expectations may be unrealistic.

| improve this answer | |
  • Editing the question is good advice. As for your last sentence, I don't have that level of expectation. – Cape Code Jan 21 '14 at 21:21
6

Unfortunately, you cannot predict what you will get by offering a bounty. It does not garantee new answers or better answers. It simply puts it in a different section with other featured questions and therefore, making it easier to spot amongs all questions on SO.

Now for the fact that you didn't get any new answers I think the first comment that you have on your post is quite self-explanatory :

DE, your post is a little bit out of scope; SO is for small response. You have an image processing (segmentation) issue you can find a lot of code at mathworks.com/matlabcentral . Try mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/… for instance. Border the answer to few possibilities, then guys will help you; at the moment the issue is too vague.

| improve this answer | |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .