This question already has an answer here:

Some questions are being answered quickly in on of the comments; in some cases, the OP even "accepts" (in words, in another comment) the comment-answer.

Here's an example.

The problem is that such questions are stuck forever in the "Unanswered" section, as there's really no need to add a formal answer, and the OP is probably never going to look for new answers, and it is already informative as is for google-comers.

In any meaningful sense - this question is answered.

What can we do with such questions?

I've seen here and there ad-hoc requests such as "please phrase this as an answer so I could accept it"; but that's really specific (and quite annoying). Should we allow OPs to "accept" a comment as an answer (I know this was discussed here, but that's a very old discussion), or should we allow moderators to flag old questions as answered if it's clear that an answer exists and the OP is ok with it? (this is similar to that offer, but is still different)

I know there have been many discussions touching the subject from various aspects, but this is a very specific offer: let moderators flag a question as answered when it has no answers, it has an "answer" in the comments, and it is clear the OP is "accepting" that answer. I have not seen that specific offer here.

marked as duplicate by michaelb958, hims056, psubsee2003, Martijn Pieters, ale Feb 17 '14 at 16:00

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.


There are several ways The CommunityTM can handle this situation already:

  1. Leave a comment for the user who answered the question to turn the comment into an answer. I would add that I normally check the profile to see if the user was recently active on SO.

  2. If the comment refers to another question (or its answer), check if a close as duplicate is reasonable.

  3. Write up an answer yourself. If you're merely copying the text from commenters, give them credit and mark your answer as Community Wiki.

Involving a moderator (which would require at the moment an "other" flag) doesn't seem to be a good idea at the moment given the current workload of the mods.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .