9

Recently-ish, over on Stack Apps, the post for the official Android app was edited to actually contain information, rather than just being a placeholder. During this process, the staff member clearly copied a bulleted list in, as indicated by this Markdown source excerpt:

• Track all your interests in one place with the new combined feed view
• Get instant notifications when you receive an answer or comment
• Search for questions, or browse by tag
• Ask, answer, comment and vote on questions

In source view, this looks fine. But try to render it, and:

• Track all your interests in one place with the new combined feed view • Get instant notifications when you receive an answer or comment • Search for questions, or browse by tag • Ask, answer, comment and vote on questions

I edited the post to use * instead of to start list items, and all was good. But it got me thinking about U+2022 BULLET, the unsung hero of unordered lists. I mean, it's the default list-item-start display character in just about everything, and yet it's not recognised as such in source:

* `*` list item
• `•` list item
+ `+` list item
- `-` list item
  • * list item • list item
  • + list item
  • - list item

Really.

End the discrimination against U+2022!

2

I'm afraid it will just add more confusion than it solves.

  • Assuming "it's the default list-item-start display character in just about everything" is true, many other bullets will look like that round bullet, but would then not trigger rendering into a list. Confusion.

  • Where to stop? Nested lists often use different bullets, but would be ignored. Confusion. (And what about <strong>, <em>, formatted links, ...?)

  • Automatically changing the bullets into proper Markdown list identifiers (right after pasting, not while saving a post) would probably be very annoying when one actually wants that character for something else.

Given the above, I don't feel it's worth another deviation from the Markdown specification, which might break rendering of apps using the API or data dumps.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .