11

I just approved a suggested edit on this post. Presumably, the edit was started before Oded added , and so the suggested edit was submitted without that tag. This is a regression of a formerly-fixed bug.

  • 4
    Looks like it's time to get some edits going for the highest voted status-declined posts and change the course of history! – mhlester Apr 22 '14 at 19:46
  • Yup. I started the edit before the tag was added, but submitted it immediately after I saw an edit had been made (didn't check what the edit was). I take it you didn't have the option to revert the inadvertent removal of the new tag because only mods can add it? BTW, you link to a duplicate of Why am I allowed to delete moderator-only tags?, which got the actual status-completed tag. – Nick Stauner Apr 22 '14 at 19:47
  • Reproduced. The case where the user adds a suggested edit before a protected tag added via an edit is handled, but the other way around (employee ads status-* tag, while the user already has the edit UI open) it's not. – m0sa Apr 23 '14 at 9:10
7

The fix implemented in the past only of the case where a user won the re-tagging race against a mod. For that to happen we the mod had to open the edit UI before the (suggested) edit was save. However, it did not take care of the case where the order of events was reversed.

Now, whenever there a normal user tries to save a (suggest or full) edit, and there is a new revision which has mod-only tags (whereas the revision the user is editing hasn't), the user will get an error message prompting him to apply his edits to the latest revision. Unfortunately this requires reloading of the page. Luckily though, this is merely enforcing users to act as suggested in the realtime notification on top they already see.

The described fix will roll out with build rev 2014.4.23.2183 on meta and 2014.4.23.1563 on sites.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .