3

Look there. It shows that my reputation on Stack Overflow is 1,553. Actually, it is 2,081.

Now look at April 20. It shows that my rep on SO was 259, and my rep on MSE was 129. Wrong, again. That day it was 730 on SO and 101 on MSE - I have just registered on MSE.

Then look at May, 15. It shows 1,323 on SO and 174 on MSE. Actually, I had 1860 rep on SO and, well 167 on MSE, almost right. Now it shows right rep for MSE and completely wrong for SO and shows negative rep for a period since April 10 to April 16 .


/reputation:
total votes: 1309
 2  19853362 (10)
-- 2013-11-08 rep +10   = 11        
 2  19875930 (10)
-- 2013-11-09 rep +10   = 21        
 2  19876868 (10)
-- 2013-11-11 rep +10   = 31        
-- 2013-11-12 rep 0     = 31        
 3  19950944 (-1)
-- 2013-11-13 rep -1    = 30        
-- 2013-11-15 rep 0     = 30        
-- 2013-11-16 rep 0     = 30        
-- 2013-11-17 rep 0     = 30        
-- 2013-11-26 rep 0     = 30        
 3  19042364 (-1)
-- 2013-11-27 rep -1    = 29        
 3  20269669 (-2)
 3  20269669 (-2)
 3  20269669 (-2)
 3  20269669 (-2)
 3  20269669 (-2)
 2  20269669 (5)
 3  20269669 (-2)
 2  20269669 (5)
 2  20269669 (5)
 2  20269669 (5)
 2  20269669 (5)
 2  20269669 (5)
-- 2013-11-28 rep +18   = 47        
 1  20285874 (2)
 1  20270525 (2)
 2  20288609 (5)
 1  20288650 (2)
 3  20288609 (-2)
-- 2013-11-29 rep +9    = 56        
 16 20299742 (2)
 16 20299957 (2)
 3  20285404 (-2)
-- 2013-11-30 rep +2    = 58        
-- 2013-12-01 rep 0     = 58        
-- 2013-12-15 rep 0     = 58        
-- 2013-12-18 rep 0     = 58        
-- 2013-12-25 rep 0     = 58        
-- 2014-01-05 rep 0     = 58        
 2  20101469 (5)
-- 2014-02-10 rep +5    = 63        
 2  20101469 (5)
-- 2014-02-14 rep +5    = 68        
-- 2014-04-01 rep 0     = 68        
 1  22814578 (2)
-- 2014-04-02 rep +2    = 70        
 3  22846204 (-2)
 2  22846204 (5)
-- 2014-04-03 rep +3    = 73        
 1  22846482 (2)
 1  22866553 (2)
-- 2014-04-04 rep +4    = 77        
 16 19680907 (2)
 16 22554131 (2)
 16 22882120 (2)
 16 22882083 (2)
 16 22882283 (2)
 16 22882253 (2)
 16 22882230 (2)
 16 22882389 (2)
 16 22882372 (2)
 16 22882427 (2)
 16 22882547 (2)
 16 22882519 (2)
 16 22882444 (2)
 16 22882679 (2)
 16 22882791 (2)
 16 22882761 (2)
 16 22882797 (2)
 16 22882962 (2)
 16 22883030 (2)
 16 22882992 (2)
 16 22883063 (2)
 16 22883091 (2)
 16 22883112 (2)
 16 22883267 (2)
 16 22884050 (2)
 16 22884478 (2)
 16 22884538 (2)
 16 22884593 (2)
 16 22884903 (2)
 1  22871567 (2)
 16 22885548 (2)
 16 22885617 (2)
 16 22885724 (2)
 2  22884393 (10)
-- 2014-04-05 rep +76   = 153       
 16 22890351 (2)
 16 22890290 (2)
 16 22890364 (2)
 16 22890386 (2)
 16 22890400 (2)
 16 22890432 (2)
 2  22890703 (5)
 1  22890730 (2)
 16 22891191 (2)
 1  22893458 (2)
 16 22893596 (2)
 2  22893937 (10)
 1  22893937 (15)
-- 2014-04-06 rep +50   = 203       
 16 22915436 (2)
 1  22915419 (15)
 2  22916393 (10)
 2  22916393 (10)
 2  22916393 (10)
 16 22917181 (2)
 16 22918060 (2)
 1  22918496 (15)
 2  22919791 (10)
 3  22919791 (-2)
 2  22894063 (10)
-- 2014-04-07 rep +84   = 287       
 16 22935776 (2)
 16 22935819 (2)
 2  22936509 (10)
 16 22936654 (2)
 2  22937901 (5)
 2  22937901 (5)
 2  22937901 (5)
 1  22937930 (2)
 2  22939126 (10)
 1  22944171 (2)
 2  22884393 (10)
 3  22944104 (-2)
 2  22936509 (10)
-- 2014-04-08 rep +63   = 350       
 16 22959884 (2)
 2  22944844 (10)
 2  22962179 (10)
 1  22966829 (2)
 16 22969028 (2)
 2  22969476 (10)
 2  22969476 (10)
 1  22962179 (15)
 2  22969476 (10)
 2  22969346 (10)
 2  22970786 (10)
-- 2014-04-09 rep +91   = 441       
 3  22944844 (-2)
 1  22939126 (15)
-- 2014-04-10 rep +13   = 454       
 1  22937468 (15)
-- 2014-04-16 rep +15   = 469       
 16 23132268 (2)
 1  23132150 (15)
 2  23132150 (10)
 2  23136999 (10)
 16 23137250 (2)
 16 23137270 (2)
 16 23137283 (2)
 16 23103101 (2)
 2  23139149 (10)
 1  23139149 (15)
-- 2014-04-17 rep +70   = 539       
 2  23155918 (10)
 2  23155918 (10)
 1  23155918 (15)
 1  23156118 (15)
-- 2014-04-18 rep +50   = 589       
-- bonuses   (100)
 2  23171575 (10)
 1  23171575 (15)
 2  23171575 (10)
 2  23156118 (10)
-- 2014-04-19 rep +145  = 734       
 16 23178659 (2)
 16 23178659 (2)
 16 23179146 (2)
 16 23179188 (2)
 16 23179243 (2)
 16 23179248 (2)
 1  23179405 (15)
-- 2014-04-20 rep +27   = 761       
-- 2014-04-21 rep 0     = 761       
-- 2014-04-22 rep 0     = 761       
 16 23245570 (2)
 2  23251848 (10)
 1  23251848 (15)
 3  23251662 (-1)
 8  22881919 (-50)
-- 2014-04-23 rep -24   = 737       
 3  23265154 (-1)
 2  23265602 (10)
 2  23265602 (10)
 16 23265655 (2)
 3  23265602 (-2)
 16 23267017 (2)
 16 23266612 (2)
 3  23267694 (-2)
 3  23267694 (-2)
 16 23267724 (2)
 16 23267773 (2)
 16 23267827 (2)
 2  23267694 (10)
 16 23267910 (2)
 16 23267936 (2)
 16 23267950 (2)
 16 23267972 (2)
 16 23268063 (2)
 16 23268010 (2)
 16 23268097 (2)
 16 23268133 (2)
 16 23268202 (2)
 16 23268284 (2)
 16 23268233 (2)
 16 23268287 (2)
 16 23269541 (2)
 16 23269593 (2)
 16 23269674 (2)
 16 23269289 (2)
 16 23269855 (2)
-- 2014-04-24 rep +69   = 806       
 2  23295469 (10)
 16 23300252 (2)
 2  23300473 (10)
-- 2014-04-25 rep +22   = 828       
 2  23264530 (10)
 1  23264530 (15)
 16 23311005 (2)
 2  23311320 (10)
 1  23311814 (15)
 2  23311999 (10)
 2  23312284 (10)
 2  23311999 (10)
 2  23311814 (10)
 3  23267694 (-2)
 2  22881919 (5)
 2  23311149 (10)
 1  23311149 (15)
-- 2014-04-26 rep +120  = 948       
 3  23322625 (-2)
 2  23322625 (10)
 2  23322625 (10)
-- 2014-04-27 rep +18   = 966       
 2  23343682 (10)
 1  23343682 (15)
 2  23346630 (10)
 2  23346630 (10)
 2  23346630 (10)
 1  23346630 (15)
 3  23348720 (-2)
 2  23348720 (10)
 2  23348720 (10)
 2  23349433 (10)
 1  23349912 (15)
 2  23349912 (10)
 1  23350358 (15)
 3  23348720 (-2)
-- 2014-04-28 rep +136  = 1102      
 2  23356395 (10)
 2  23365079 (10)
 2  23366362 (10)
 2  23366362 (10)
 2  23367379 (10)
 2  23368866 (10)
 2  23368866 (10)
 2  23368866 (10)
 1  23324445 (15)
 1  23374775 (2)
-- 2014-04-29 rep +97   = 1199      
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 2  22881919 (5)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 2  22881919 (5)
 3  22881919 (-2)
 3  22881919 (-2)
-- 2014-04-30 rep -20   = 1179      
 16 23421201 (2)
-- 2014-05-04 rep +2    = 1181      
 1  22968948 (2)
 16 23477648 (2)
 16 23480697 (2)
 16 23481946 (2)
-- 2014-05-05 rep +8    = 1189      
 16 23500348 (2)
 2  23500736 (10)
 2  23503454 (10)
 2  23504067 (10)
 2  23504067 (10)
 2  23504067 (10)
 1  23504067 (15)
-- 2014-05-06 rep +67   = 1256      
 2  23524410 (10)
 2  23524410 (10)
-- 2014-05-07 rep +20   = 1276      
-- 2014-05-08 rep 0     = 1276      
 1  23544588 (15)
 16 23568820 (2)
 2  23568843 (5)
 1  23569589 (2)
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23569087 (10)
-- 2014-05-09 rep +39   = 1315      
 2  23581634 (10)
 16 23572072 (2)
 16 23480416 (2)
 16 23453428 (2)
 16 23459245 (2)
 16 23456868 (2)
 16 22760839 (2)
 16 22734636 (2)
 16 23005177 (2)
 16 22837139 (2)
 16 22878183 (2)
 16 22458712 (2)
 16 22369922 (2)
 16 22379316 (2)
 16 22234485 (2)
 16 22596469 (2)
 16 21899332 (2)
 16 21663627 (2)
 16 22100276 (2)
 16 21957113 (2)
 16 21668148 (2)
 16 22074115 (2)
 16 21504613 (2)
 16 21402607 (2)
 16 20654826 (2)
 16 21884326 (2)
 16 19929893 (2)
 16 21743718 (2)
 16 19851494 (2)
 16 20437131 (2)
 16 19639465 (2)
 16 20528401 (2)
 16 19974285 (2)
 16 20018171 (2)
 16 20102792 (2)
 16 20025344 (2)
 16 20283608 (2)
 16 20026805 (2)
 16 19358156 (2)
 16 19472615 (2)
 16 18804985 (2)
 16 19371911 (2)
 16 18812190 (2)
 16 18737539 (2)
 16 18755075 (2)
 16 18807310 (2)
 16 19437481 (2)
 16 18837281 (2)
 16 18837937 (2)
 16 19278859 (2)
 16 19331899 (2)
 16 19351065 (2)
 16 18361696 (2)
 16 18437162 (2)
 16 18392803 (2)
 16 18430656 (2)
 16 18334438 (2)
 16 18361143 (2)
 16 18331572 (2)
 16 18316110 (2)
 16 18385671 (2)
 16 18378993 (2)
 16 18287533 (2)
 16 18098055 (2)
 16 18065400 (2)
 16 18244726 (2)
 16 17495273 (2)
 16 18037752 (2)
 16 17523814 (2)
 16 17415464 (2)
 16 17078947 (2)
 16 16821879 (2)
 16 17158825 (2)
 16 16921136 (2)
 16 16915118 (2)
 16 16702797 (2)
 16 16698213 (2)
 16 16682328 (2)
 16 16599183 (2)
 16 16582677 (2)
 16 15984087 (2)
 16 16221359 (2)
 16 15960511 (2)
 16 15833060 (2)
 16 15463831 (2)
 16 15639293 (2)
 16 14803222 (2)
 16 15417174 (2)
 16 15629552 (2)
 16 14784483 (2)
 16 14446506 (2)
 16 14046400 (2)
 16 14339844 (2)
 16 14091707 (2)
 16 15184803 (2)
 16 13908329 [2]
 16 13474786 [0]
 16 13390401 [0]
 3  22937901 [-2]
 16 13364105 [2]
 16 13792980 [0]
 16 13345191 [0]
 16 13094536 [0]
 16 13271961 [0]
 16 13034935 [0]
 16 12998200 [0]
 16 13371811 [0]
-- 2014-05-10 rep +200  = 1515      
 1  23584504 (15)
 16 23589291 (2)
 1  23589578 (15)
 1  23590361 (15)
 2  23590463 (10)
 2  23590463 (10)
 2  23592412 (10)
 1  23592412 (15)
 2  23593070 (10)
 16 23593672 (2)
 2  23594122 (10)
 2  23594122 (10)
 1  23590463 (15)
 2  23596023 (10)
 16 19146341 (2)
 16 18848457 (2)
 16 19075472 (2)
 16 19121048 (2)
 16 18949689 (2)
 16 18901669 (2)
 16 18944800 (2)
 16 18812190 (2)
 16 18667253 (2)
 16 18615939 (2)
 16 17634245 (2)
 16 17700216 (2)
 16 17825728 (2)
 16 16905035 (2)
 16 17440926 (2)
 16 17224842 (2)
 16 17407918 (2)
 16 22920900 (2)
 16 21397021 (2)
 16 19752843 (2)
 16 21153697 (2)
 16 19959953 (2)
 16 11585030 (2)
 16 11136217 (2)
 16  9256661 (2)
 16 10941588 (2)
 16  9089532 (2)
 16  7582540 (2)
 16 11550066 (2)
 16  6792542 (2)
 16 12557180 (2)
 16  6853865 (2)
 16  6327157 (2)
 16  5963182 (2)
 16  6279292 (2)
 16  4425885 (2)
 16  4032495 (2)
 16  3503471 (2)
 16  2882861 (2)
 16   383185 (2)
 16  2819837 (2)
 16   383172 (2)
 16   383189 (2)
 16  2739515 (2)
 16  1026495 (2)
 16   502138 (2)
 16   386044 (2)
 16   385960 (2)
 16   383201 (2)
 16   458453 (2)
 16   390992 (2)
 16   366031 (2)
 16   366047 (2)
 16   109399 (2)
 16   402538 (2)
 16 12431597 (2)
 16  3863454 (2)
 16 18527447 (2)
 16 17256961 (2)
-- 2014-05-11 rep +267  = 1782      
 2  23581634 (10)
 1  23581634 (15)
 16 23601636 (2)
 2  23612559 (10)
-- 2014-05-12 rep +37   = 1819      
 1  23612559 (15)
-- 2014-05-13 rep +15   = 1834      
 2  23663537 (10)
-- 2014-05-14 rep +10   = 1844      
 2  23682737 (10)
 3  23682737 (-2)
 1  23682737 (15)
 8  23568843 (-50)
-- 2014-05-15 rep -27   = 1817      
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23697058 (10)
 2  23663537 (10)
 2  23697058 (10)
-- 2014-05-16 rep +35   = 1852      
 2  23716348 (10)
-- 2014-05-17 rep +10   = 1862      
 2  23718863 (10)
 1  22630013 (2)
 2  23722781 (5)
 2  23722572 (10)
 2  23722781 (5)
 1  23723036 (2)
 2  23722491 (10)
 1  23722572 (15)
 2  23568843 (5)
 16 23726152 (2)
 16 23726188 (2)
-- 2014-05-18 rep +68   = 1930      
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23742849 (10)
 2  23737776 (5)
-- 2014-05-19 rep +35   = 1965      
-- 2014-05-20 rep 0     = 1965      
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23568843 (5)
 16 23784203 (2)
 16 23786765 (2)
 16 23786950 (2)
 2  23787428 (10)
 2  23568843 (5)
 3  23787428 (-2)
-- 2014-05-21 rep +29   = 1994      
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23568843 (5)
 3  23808466 (-1)
 2  23504067 (10)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23524410 (10)
-- 2014-05-22 rep +44   = 2038      
 8  23737776 (-50)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
-- 2014-05-24 rep -35   = 2003      
-- 2014-05-25 rep 0     = 2003      
 2  23568843 (5)
 2  23872599 (10)
-- 2014-05-26 rep +15   = 2018      
 2  23179405 (10)
 2  22915419 (10)
 3  23737776 (-2)
 2  23737776 (5)
 3  23737776 (-2)
-- 2014-05-27 rep +21   = 2039      
-- 2014-05-28 rep 0     = 2039      
 2  22937468 (10)
-- 2014-05-29 rep +10   = 2049      
 2  23737776 (5)
 3  23737776 (-2)
 2  23737776 (5)
-- 2014-05-30 rep +8    = 2057      
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  23737776 (5)
 1  23848870 (2)
-- 2014-05-31 rep +12   = 2069      
 2  23568843 (5)
-- 2014-06-01 rep +5    = 2074      
 3  23737776 (-2)
 2  23993579 (5)
 3  23993579 (-2)
 2  23993579 (5)
 2  20268024 (10)
-- 2014-06-02 rep +16   = 2090      
 1  23993660 (2)
 1  24020507 (15)
 2  24020625 (10)
 2  24020625 (10)
 3  24020507 (-2)
 2  24020625 (10)
 2  24020625 (10)
-- 2014-06-03 rep +55   = 2145      
 2  23737776 (5)
 2  24042138 (10)
 2  24020625 (10)
-- 2014-06-04 rep +25   = 2170      
 1  24042138 (15)
-- 2014-06-05 rep +15   = 2185      

** rep today: 15
** rep this week (2014-06-01 - 2014-06-07): 116
** rep this month (2014-06-01 - 2014-06-30): 116
** rep this quarter (2014-04-01 - 2014-06-30): 2117
** rep this year (2014-01-01 - 2014-12-31): 2127
** rep from bonuses: 100
** total rep 2185 :)
  • 4
    It's also showing you had negative reputation on a few days, which just shouldn't be possible. – Adam Lear May 31 '14 at 19:09
  • @AnnaLear Yes, -48. Really strange. – nicael May 31 '14 at 19:10
  • @nicael - You are right, I misread it. – Travis J May 31 '14 at 20:50
  • 1
    What do you see when you go to here? – user206222 Jun 4 '14 at 22:56
  • @Emrakul It shows my actual rep, without any surprises. – nicael Jun 5 '14 at 4:35
  • @nicael Is the total reputation at any point negative? – user206222 Jun 5 '14 at 4:35
  • @Emrakul No. It is negative in graph only. – nicael Jun 5 '14 at 4:37
  • It'd be interesting if you could share the output of the reputation link. You might want to sanitize it by removing the lines with (-1) which is answers you downvoted. Then someone could make a new graph, compare it with the SE graph, and find what caused the discrepancy. My guess is it's the rep change events, but obviously can't say for sure – mhlester Jun 5 '14 at 16:06
  • @mhlester done. I haven't got any "rep change" events on SO, only there. – nicael Jun 5 '14 at 16:08
  • 1
    @Anna looks like Nick found the reason, so nothing weird anymore. :) – Shadow Wizard is Vaccinating Oct 28 '14 at 12:32
10
+700

I've graphed the data from your SE graph and your /reputation page:

enter image description here


Analyzing that data, I found a discrepancy on 22 days

On these days, the graph increased more than /reputation:

Date       Graph  /rep   Diff
2013-11-11    50    10     40
2013-11-15    70     0     70
2013-11-17    10     0     10
2013-11-26    55     0     55
2013-11-28   126    18    108
2013-11-29   147     9    138
2013-11-30    10     2      8
2014-04-02   160     2    158
2014-04-09   106    91     15
2014-04-29   107    97     10
2014-05-11   269   267      2
2014-05-16    50    35     15
2014-05-18    83    68     15

And on these days /reputation increased more than the graph:

Date       Graph  /rep   Diff
2013-12-01  -129     0    129
2014-04-03  -105     3    108
2014-04-04  -126     4    130
2014-04-05    72    76      4
2014-04-10  -720    13    733
2014-04-30   -30   -20     10
2014-05-19     5    35     30
2014-05-25   -10     0     10
2014-06-03    53    55      2

Looking at your reputation history, for 2014-04-10, the largest discrepancy, I see this:

Spot checking other days from the second group, they all seem to have a User was removed entry. The first group likely represents the days those users voted on your posts.


Conclusion:

  • The /reputation page shows no data on removed users, as if they'd never existed
  • The reputation profile page shows removed users on the date they were removed, and earlier votes are still displayed on the day of the vote.
  • The reputation graph on SE does both of these! It seems to remove votes in the manner of /reputation, but then also removes reputation a second time on the date the user was removed.
  • Many thanks! Very useful! If anyone won't provide me an explanations why it happened, I'll give you this bounty. – nicael Jun 6 '14 at 17:27
5

After the cleanup that happened here just now, the SE.com profile page should be correct after the next pull that'll happen tonight around midnight UTC. Peripheral systems like this are why cleanup on history was necessary here.

  • 1
    The graph doesn't appear to have changed. Are you sure the graph isn't double-counting user was removed events? See my answer here. It seems to solve the problem – mhlester Jun 23 '14 at 16:24
  • Really, my SO rep is -323 now, could you fix it plz. – nicael Jun 29 '14 at 20:12
  • It is not completed. Please either complete it or remove [status-completed]. – nicael Oct 19 '14 at 4:21
  • Plzzzzzzz fixxx it! – nicael Oct 25 '14 at 22:30
  • 4
    @nicael this is the result of multiple sock puppet accounts being deleted, bounties awarded you did not have rep for, and non-standard reputation fixes to account for the differences in both with are pretty much specific to you. This isn't something we'll invest dev time in anytime soon. Do you really want to go down the road of why your reputation is so far off? The quickest solution for us here is to wipe the slate and not have your colorful history be and insane outlier, rather than patch around an issue for a few of over 5 million accounts in the same boat - self created in each case. – Nick Craver Oct 26 '14 at 8:58
  • 3
    @Nick can you please update the answer as well to reflect the reason of declining the request? (different wording of course) – Shadow Wizard is Vaccinating Oct 26 '14 at 9:17
  • 1
    @Nick Thanks for your great effort!!! And update the answer, please. – nicael Oct 26 '14 at 9:25
0

Disclaimer: this is not the official answer, just explaining why this bug report is declined.

As Nick explains in a comment, this behavior is specific to the OP here who has done lots of things that, to put it nicely, should not really have been done.

Since this will not happen to all other millions of users, the request to fix this one instance was declined.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .