10

Granted most of the questions asked here are way over my head but in the rare occasion where I see a question I can assist with, Im more than happy to offer my time.

I just looked up one of my old answers and saw that the user basically took my answer, changed the directory a little, submitted it and chose it as the accepted answer? Does this happen often?

I guess this kinda irked me..

  • If you want an answer from the OP, why he didn't accept your answer, you should comment his question, not your answer. – Ladybug Killer Sep 25 '09 at 8:00
  • its behind me, besides, what good would it do? – Locutus Sep 25 '09 at 11:33
  • 1
    I don't know, DataPimp. You asked the question ;) – Ladybug Killer Sep 25 '09 at 12:32
  • 1
    I've even seen someone copy the correct answer into someone else's wrong answer, and then accept that for a bounty... stackoverflow.com/questions/767236/… Odd ;-) – Arjan Mar 19 '10 at 13:10
15

I don't think that guy was being malicious (after all he doesn't get any rep for accepting his own answer).

Basically I think the issue just came down to the fact that the folder you pointed to didn't exist on his machine, and he wasn't familiar enough with windows to know that C:/Documents and Settings/ is the Windows XP structure and that he should replace it with C:/Users for his Windows 7 install.

  • But, the user was still correct, because DataPimp's answer didn't answer the question. – devinb Sep 25 '09 at 12:56
  • (Just for the archives, as the OP removed the link to the question: the copied answer is stackoverflow.com/questions/1458086/…, originally posted as "DataPimp", now owned by "Leroy Jenkins".) – Arjan Mar 19 '10 at 16:59
12

I've had this happen. It sucks... The user had a chance to reward you for your help, and didn't. Some people are like that. Just brush it off and move on.

7

If it was a pure copy, I would be mad, but I think there is a bit of difference to show that he did try your version and it didn't help him. - And as TM said, he probably did not realise / understand.

I had a similar issue on Superuser.com where I posted a link showing you need to use %userprofile%\something (I forget now), and then the owner, about 20 minutes later wrote the full thing "C:\users\name\something" and accepted, where as if he actually tried my thing, it should have worked on any version of Windows.

He even wrote, I went to My computer and could not find the %userprofile% directory... oh well!

Also, you don't know, he may have given you an upvote in that thread :S

  • 5
    Yeah, I think the issue in this particular thread is just that the asker didn't even realize that the other guy answered his question correctly. It's easy to assume a certain level of knowledge that isn't always there. – TM. Sep 24 '09 at 22:38
  • 1
    @TM +1 I agree... I haven't looked in to this person, but unless he had done it several times, like in my example, I do not think it is malicious. – William Hilsum Sep 24 '09 at 22:39
  • Oh I agree not malicious, but seriously... how close does it have to be.. once he found the directory and deleted it, you would think.. hmmm, that sure sounds familiar. :) Shog9 is right, its past me now. – Locutus Sep 24 '09 at 23:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .