I've noticed several Stack Exchange election nomination phases follow this pattern:


On Unix and Linux, we had no activity for 5 days, and then two more nominations suddenly came in within a couple hours of the deadline. The problem with this is commenting is no longer obviously accessible once nominations end; you have to know to go back to the nomination tab, and be bothered enough to do so.

Personally I think comments should be open and visible the entire election, even during voting. The vote buttons should show up when the election phase starts, but the comments shouldn't disappear. If there's some reason not to do that, I think there should be a window where no nominations are accepted, but the voting hasn't started yet, so that everyone can comment on nominations without people slipping in at the last minute before the phase ends.

  • This also prevents people from waiting until the last minute to prevent comments. (not sure that has ever happened, but it could) – ɥʇǝS Jun 17 '14 at 1:15
  • @ɥʇǝS I've seen several cases where I think nominations were posted at the last minute specifically to avoid the feedback cycle everybody else was going through, so this is more than a hypothetical problem ;-) – Caleb Jul 30 '14 at 9:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .