One of the lesser-known features in Area 51 lets you generate little sidebar-ad-sized images to promote proposals you're interested in, like this one:

Stack Exchange Q&A site proposal: Coffee

To use it, click the "Share This" link under the number of followers/committers and look in the bottom half of the pop-up. It'll give you the URL for an image that is generated dynamically, and so is theoretically good indefinitely regardless of when you post it.

The script that generates these images still works for sites that have already entered beta. I just saw the following at SDLtridionworld.com:

Stack Exchange Q&A site proposal: Tridion

I think it looks a little weird to have "n days in beta" in the same place as "new site proposal." It's also possible to view even more misleading images for old proposals that have closed down (e.g. Firearms) or graduated into full site-hood (e.g. Arqade):

Stack Exchange Q&A site proposal: Firearms Stack Exchange Q&A site proposal: Gaming (Arqade)

Can we alter the script that generates these a bit, so that they're more suitable for all the stages a proposal might actually be in (definition/commitment, private/public beta, &c.)?

For beta sites, we could replace "new site proposal" with something like "beta Q&A site" (and then change "view beta info" to "view site info" so the word "beta" doesn't show up three times), and for closed/graduated sites we could return a generic A51 ad. I'd rather not 404 anything entirely and cause broken images on the sites of people who were, at least at one point, attempting to support us.

  • 2
    Any suggestions for what these should look like for other site types? Especially closed proposals. I'm thinking we should just 404 instead of generating an ad for those. – Adam Lear Aug 20 '14 at 23:05
  • D'oh, lost this tab behind another window. Updated. @AnnaLear – Pops Sep 10 '14 at 16:07

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .