4

There are 4 locations where user badges and reputation are displayed on StackExchange:

  1. The top bar
  2. The profile
  3. On the "Users" page
  4. Everywhere else (ie. On questions, answers, edits, etc.)

In each of these locations, we see the user's reputation and badges. For all of them, the wording of mouse over text for badges is consistent, but for reputation, the mouse over text is different.

  1. The top bar:

    "your reputation: 1,000" (colon, comma)

    Imgur

  2. The profile:

    no mouse over text.

    Imgur

    However, this one actually makes some sense that it would be different, since the reputation on the profile is a link to the reputation tab.

  3. On the "Users" page:

    "total reputation: 1000" (colon, no comma)

    Imgur

  4. Everywhere else:

    "reputation score" if reputation < 10k,

    Imgur

    else "reputation score 10000" (no colon, no comma)

    Imgur

Can we make the mouse over text uniform across all these locations?

Personally, I like the wording "1,000 reputation" (number first, include commas, no "score") as it reads very naturally and is the same as the badge mouse overs (except that badge counts don't have commas).

(It's probable I missed a few locations that don't exactly fall under "everywhere else")

  • The tooltips are consistent with the use case of that location – Martijn Pieters Oct 9 '14 at 21:58
  • 1
    The top-bar tooltip explains what the number is for, just like there is a tooltip for the other 3 numbers. The usercards have abbreviated scores after 10k, so the tooltip gives you the full score. The user page reputation is clearly labelled 'reputation' and shows your full score anyway. – Martijn Pieters Oct 9 '14 at 22:30
  • The last case (missing commas outside users page when rep >= 10k) seems to have been fixed. As of this writing, the others have not been changed AFAICT. – Ilmari Karonen Apr 14 '16 at 12:37
3

I just pushed fix that add commas to all these locations.

With you in the next build.

2

I agree that these tooltips could use some improvement. In fact, I've just added a client-side fix that addresses some of these issues into the SOUP user script. (It's already in the devel branch, and will be part of v1.34 when it's released.)

The fix appends the reputation score to the tooltip if it's missing, and formats the numbers nicely with commas, like this:

Reputation score appended to tooltip
Commas inserted into reputation score
Comma insertion also works on the Users page

The fix also applies to expanded user cards (which, apparently, don't show the rep in the tooltip unless it's over 10k):

Fixes also apply to expanded user cards

It doesn't (or, at least, shouldn't) apply to any rep scores outside user cards, such as those in the profile. It also doesn't modify the text of the tooltips in any way; it only reformats the rep counts (and inserts them, if necessary).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .