I recently voted to close a question as "too broad;" several others chose "primarily opinion-based." When the question was put on hold, the message shown was:
put on hold as primarily opinion-based by user1, user2, T.J. Crowder, user3, user4
This has always bothered me: Could we please make that message accurate?
put on hold as
primarily opinion-based by user1, user2, user4
too broad by T.J. Crowder, user3
I don't see it reducing comprehension (to the extent people read it at all), and may well give some useful additional feedback to the OP (to the extent people read it at all).
This particular example is a "meh" (e.g., the question was probably both), but I've sometimes felt the need to actually add a comment disassociating myself from a close reason that made no sense (but was the one the majority picked).