7

Self answered questions have misordered timeline. Because it is old tech that may go it is not gong to be repaired. However...

enter image description here

This is from the profile page 0 the Answer comes before (well after, before in time) the Question.

They both have exactly the same UTC-time-hover, so perhaps posting the answer 1 second later would solve this issue?

  • Given that the question and answer were posted at the same exact instant, they have the exact same timestamp. Your screen shot, however, shows the question before the answer - is that what you are trying to say is wrong? – Oded Apr 25 '15 at 20:11
  • It shows the Answer before, it is lower down... It thinks the Answer is older. – Tim Apr 25 '15 at 20:20
  • They both have the same exact "age". It can be argued that having the exact same time stamp, either one should be first. – Oded Apr 25 '15 at 20:23
6

As both Question and Answer have the same posted time in a Self Answered question, showing the Question or Answer in any order is correct - "based on time".

However, I can see why you still want a Q before A in listings even for a Self Answered, because for an Answer to exist you need a Question, and so logically an Answer should come after a Question.

There is the other argument, that this is "Self Answered" and not a "normal" Q&A, and so there are differences. In this case an Answer does not come after a Question, they do come at the same time.
However, arguments aside, I would say that it's better for us (most) "humans" to see a Q before an A in listings.
It just seems more logical and "comfortable" that way.

Not a bug:
I'd argue this is not a bug though, it's by-design as the system simply lists things based on time.
So I would assume if you want to get it changed you'd need a feature request.


Options:

  1. Answer's post time in Self Answered to be advanced to after the Question's post time
  2. Relevant list scripts identify Self Answered questions and list Q before A
  3. Relevant lists visually identify when a Q or A is from a Self Answered

(1)
I disagree with advancing the time of the Answer.
This is not correct, as they are by nature and logic posted "at the same time" and should therefore have the same post times.

If the time is advanced by only a short amount it might appear to be a delay in the scripts.
If time was advanced too much, say 10 mins, they would just look like a normal Q&A pair. i.e. [Q 08:00] and [A 08:10].

Users may see this as "wrong" and possibly raise questions - "Answer should have same time as Question" or "why are they not the same time".

(2)
While this is the better option, it would mean additional script time on each and every view of a page with relevant Q&A listings.

I have no idea of overhead on this though, perhaps small enough to give a good enough ROI.

(3)
This retains the logic that Self Answered Question and Answer have the same time.
And would help towards removing confusion of seeing an Answer before the Question it answered, because their being visually identified as a Self Answered Q or A would bring sense/explanation to the situation.

This could simply be having "Self" stamped somewhere on any Q and A from a Self Answered Question.

Or the current speech bubbles around the Q's and A's could be a different image - something along the lines of the Ouroboros (I know that won't happen, of course, but a nice idea..).

| improve this answer | |
-2

Self answered questions mean that the question and the answer were posted at exactly the same time.

As far as the system is concerned, one is not older than the other and can be displayed in any order.

| improve this answer | |
  • 6
    But answer can't exist on its own without a question. Common sense says that first the question is created, then it's being answered. So I would expect a manual "patch" in such cases. And profile page is way more important than timeline view. – Shadow 10 Years Wizard Apr 25 '15 at 20:32
  • 1
    I think that this deserves reconsideration... It should be the correct way round, esp on the profile page. – Tim Apr 25 '15 at 20:59
  • 1
    This is true, technically, and based on "times" only, but there's more to it than that. People logically want to see Q before A, rightly or wrongly, that is the way it is. – James Apr 26 '15 at 0:07
  • So, how much rep you want in exchange for reconsidering? ;-) – Shadow 10 Years Wizard Apr 26 '15 at 12:50
  • @ShadowWizard Doubt there is a bounty big enough ;) – Tim Apr 26 '15 at 12:53

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .