40

Someone voted to close my question as a duplicate. I agreed, so I cast my close vote (I have enough reputation to vote to close).

A question is closed immediately when the asker agrees that it's a duplicate. So I expected this to happen.

But it didn't. This confused me — is this not a question I asked after all? No, it is. Maybe I need to reload the page? Nope, the question still isn't closed. Is the asker confirmation feature broken? Well, there's the “This question may already have an answer here” banner at the top. What if I click “That solved my problem!”? Ah, that does close the question.

It turns out that only clicking “That solved my problem!” instantly closes the question. Casting a close vote has a different effect, it's just an ordinary close vote.

Please make casting a close vote equivalent to clicking “That solved my problem!”.

  • Is it really the same? You could agree with the dupe and thus vote but you could still feel it didn't solve your problem. If not enough voters agree with the dupe your question remains open. – rene Jul 26 '15 at 12:23
  • +1 I agree. -- Please make casting a close vote "on my own question" equivalent to clicking “That solved my problem!”. – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 12:23
  • 2
    @rene If you object to the “That solved my problem!”, that's a different point. What I want is for a close vote as duplicate on my own question to close it. If I didn't feel it solved my problem, I wouldn't vote to close. (And you may have a point — the other question was another unanswered MSE feature request, so it didn't solve my problem — but anyhow the difference between the two ways to seemingly do the same thing is the issue here.) – Gilles Jul 26 '15 at 12:26
  • 1
    Yessss do itttttt – Lightness Races in Orbit Jul 26 '15 at 14:19
  • Interesting to see it mainly affects long time/high rep users who are used to the existing system. – Shadow The Dragon Wizard Jul 26 '15 at 19:48
  • @ShadowWizard I can't see (due to low reps) how the current high-rep users "duplicate" close vote options look like... All I am trying to say that the current option can be reworded "I agree... and I vote to close immediately" or "I agree... and it solved my problem!". I would like undelete my answer and reword it BUT can't find the right resource. – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 20:16
  • @Hack it looks exactly the same as your flag dialog. You suggest changing the wording in the dialog in case there is existing close vote from others? It wasn't clear from your answer, I thought you meant adding extra, third, button in the banner. – Shadow The Dragon Wizard Jul 26 '15 at 20:22
  • @ShadowWizard No I did not mean to add third button... I was suggesting the rewording... do you have a screenshot of user when the question is marked as duplicate – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 20:28
  • Not at the moment @Hack sorry. – Shadow The Dragon Wizard Jul 26 '15 at 21:00
  • @ShadowWizard no problem... thanks for the helping hand. I found the resource... updated my answer – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 22:29
5

I think this can be easily solved by changing the way option(s) are given to choose when OP decides to close his own question. After all, it's the OP who wants to close the question. I can understand keeping the question open so that enough voters can agree upon the reason for the close in case of the other users who flagged the question as a duplicate. But, here it's the OP who is actually casting a close vote.

But, if the system is designed (see Note at the bottom) to ask for the confirmation/reason for the close, then how about making a little change (as suggested below) in the dialog box when OP (as the system can detect or already knows the owner of the post) decides to close the question.

As per the OP quote:

"Someone voted to close my question as a duplicate. I agreed, so I cast my close vote (I have enough reputation to vote to close)".

Based on the facts, i.e. :

  • OP (the owner) wants to close his own question.
  • OP has enough reputations to cast his close vote.
  • System recognizes (by detecting) it's the OP and not any other user.

Everything below only applies/valid for the above given facts.

Now, upon clicking the 'close' link under the question body, OP is given the options list as shown below: (Image taken from the Help Center > Privileges > Cast Close And Reopen Votes)

Cast a Close Vote

I would like to suggest the following change(s) to the above shown options window:

  1. We could add a button 3 anywhere in the bottom (may be next to "Vote To Close" button). Here, OP can cast his vote by selecting "duplicate" radio button from the options list and then clicking the "That solved my problem!" button. This should close the question immediately. Whereas, selecting a "duplicate" radio button from the options list and clicking on the "Vote to Close" button will just cast an ordinary close vote.

  2. Alternatively, we could change the "duplicate" radio button title as "duplicate... and it solved my problem!". Now, OP can simply select this radio button from the options list and click on the "Vote to Close" button to cast his close vote. This should close the question immediately. No need of "That solved my problem!" button.

With the implementation of any of the above given suggestions, it is possible for the OP to close the question immediately without needing an additional confirmation shown afterwards in the banner at the top. It will surely avoid the confusion that OP witnessed here in this particular case. I'm sure there are few more other possible ways this can be implemented, but this is what I can think of. Please share your thoughts, ideas any suggestions.

NOTE:

I am assuming this belongs to the category. Also, the close vote will not work (status by design) if there's an open bounty on the question. It would be great if someone from SE team (or moderators) could share more details on this.

  • 2
    Why yet another prompt? I said I wanted to close my question as a duplicate of that one. Why ask me “are you sure” again? – Gilles Jul 26 '15 at 12:55
  • 1
    Not even sure I understand this answer, frankly. – Lightness Races in Orbit Jul 26 '15 at 14:19
  • @LightnessRacesinOrbit Please see my edit to post. – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 14:42
  • 3
    Sorry but you are really over-complicating things here, without a good reason. If OP want to close as dupe of a different question than the one suggested by others then he/she can just cast ordinary close vote like we always did. Otherwise if OP agree it's a dupe of the same question, just clicking the "That solved my problem" is simple and to the point. And the third case, of OP who is not familiar with the new feature and casts ordinary close vote for the same question as other voters is exactly what is being proposed here. – Shadow The Dragon Wizard Jul 26 '15 at 19:52
  • @ShadowWizard thanks for this explanation, reflected in my answer. – HackerKarma Jul 26 '15 at 22:39
  • 1
    Cheers this makes more sense now. :) – Shadow The Dragon Wizard Jul 27 '15 at 4:33

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .