Last night, I tried copying a conversation from comments into chat, so it could be discussed there. However, the comments didn't onebox.

A little bit of experimenting in the Sandbox revealed that the timestamp gives different links for comments when in review.* While the link works (see here), it won't onebox in chat.

Is this a bug? ...it seems that either links to comments in the review pane should conform to the norm, but I think the real problem is in chat, since all links to comments should onebox.

* In my instance, where http://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/61682/if-a-non-religious-person-is-o‌​f-jewish-heritage-can-one-wear-the-star-of-david#comment168895_61682 is the regular link, http://judaism.stackexchange.com/q/61682/#comment168895_61682 is the link from review.

1 Answer 1


The url form you are using is less common, but indeed: valid - I'm updating chat to recognize that pattern. It should work shortly.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .