-25

I think if you have enough reputation to get the association bonus (i.e. >200 rep) you should be awarded the "read the tour" badge automatically. That way, you need not worry about buffing your bronze badge count by one by "reading" the tour page every time you join a new community.

  • 2
    Is it really that big of a struggle for you to click on "tour" and scroll down the page? FWP. – Catija Aug 10 '15 at 22:26
  • @Catija It takes 10 seconds. ...that's alot. – noɥʇʎԀʎzɐɹƆ Aug 10 '15 at 22:31
  • Wow... takes me two. – Catija Aug 10 '15 at 22:32
  • Takes me 0.88 seconds! – user289879 Aug 11 '15 at 3:46
  • 3
    @JamesLu "it takes 10 seconds" Ok, to be kind/fair, let's say it takes twice as long as you claim, so 20 seconds. Are you really saying "20 seconds is way too long a time spent to earn a badge". All you have to do is a very simple action for 20 seconds....and you get a badge...this is the easiest badge you will ever earn. In fact, given the aforementioned, I'd be inclined to make it harder for seasoned users (no change for new users) – James Aug 11 '15 at 10:26
7

Another thing is that you actually should read the some sections of the tour of a new site you are joining, especially the uppermost few sentences and what is on- and off-topic. If you don't read that, you might end up asking a Question at the wrong site.

So no, I am strongly against giving the badge just away like this. If you have to scroll through the tour you have a little chance of at least reading the uppermost few sentences.

  • 5
    This is by far the best answer here. What's on- and off-topic for various sites around the network is widely different, and you should definitely be looking through it for every site you first visit because some are not so clear-cut and contain customized information on that page. We can't assume just because you have an association bonus that you know the scope of every site, so awarding the badge on every site makes no sense. – animuson Dec 9 '15 at 22:32
19

I'm somewhat surprised that someone who is familiar enough with Stack Exchange to get the association bonus would bother "buffing" their bronze badge counts. However, just giving people things removes any value they have - there's no point having something if it's worthless.

If people do want to increase the number of bronze badges they have in this way then there's little point bespoking code to help them - it only takes a few seconds to scroll down the page.

  • 2 seconds * millions of people = several years of human time that could've gone to cancer research – noɥʇʎԀʎzɐɹƆ Aug 4 '16 at 0:56
15

Should you really make a long-time user read through the tour page to get a badge every time that person joins a new site?

Yes, because that's what is required to earn the badge.

If someone has visited the site for 99 days consecutively, should we just give them the "fanatic" badge, because, well, they've done pretty much all of the requirements, so what's one more day?

One more day is the specifics of what is required to earn that badge.
Reading the tour page is the specifics of what is required to earn the "informed" badge.

Badges are designed to encourage specific behaviours.
The "informed" badge is designed to encourage new users to read the tour page, not earn rep on sites. And having both options to earn the badge makes no sense.

I think if you have enough reputation to get the association bonus (i.e. >200 rep) you should be awarded the "read the tour" badge automatically

Why does your rep have any bearing on earning a non-rep related badge which has a specific requirement - read the tour page, not earn 200 rep.

That way, you need not worry about buffing your bronze badge count by one by "reading" the tour page every time you join a new community.

You are seeing the badges in the wrong light. They're not there to be given to you based some "I've been here years" or whatever, you earn them by doing the specific requirements.

If you don't need to read the tour page, don't, and you wont get the badge.
If you want the badge, even if you don't need to read the tour page, then read the tour page and get the badge.

It's fine if you're interested in your total badge count, but it's not exactly hard to read the tour page to get the badge.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .