19

Sometimes an OP changes their mind and awards the accepted answer mark to another post. Sometimes they don't know you can only mark one answer as accepted, and click the big checkmark next to each answer on their question without realising this un-accepts the each previous answer at the same time. The old timeline view would show you that this happened, by including accept un-accept events as separate entries.

The new timeline, spiffy as it is, doesn't include unaccepts and only shows the most recent accept vote. I'm really missing this information, it was one of the very few reasons I used the old timeline in the first place.

This is especially important for moderators, where we sometimes have to diagnose fraud where an accepted answer was plagiarised and the accept mark shifted over to the new copy. Having to hunt through the victim reputation history to try and piece together a timeline of events is so much harder now.

Can the new view please show all accepts and include un-accepts again?

4

Yes: please change this. The lack of this information gets really annoying when there are nontrivial changes in the accepted answer.

If you want an example of a question with such changes, this one is a good one. In that specific case, the OP originally accepted my answer, and then some three years later changed the accepted answer to some other one, giving me a handy populist badge in the process.

However, it seems that about a week later the OP came back and unaccepted that answer, without accepting a new one. The corresponding accept/unaccept events on the OP's reputation timeline allow you to identify the answer in question as this one, but neither the question timeline nor the timelines on my answer or the other one will inform you that any of this happened.

The point of the timeline is to let you show you the blow-by-blow history of the post, so you can piece back together stories like this one. If it gets anywhere near nontrivial, the current view is patently failing.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .