It happened again the other day on SO. I answered a question and 2 other users also answered the question. Because of the order that currently on my screen, my answer was in the middle of the 3. After a few minutes, I saw the green checkmark appear next to the answer below mine. A few seconds later, it disappeared and reappeared on my answer. Another few seconds later, it disappeared again and reappeared on the third answer above mine.

I've deduced that this has happened many times over the years on many different posts. I figure it out even when I don't have the relevant post open because my reputation score goes up by 15 without a green "+15" box. After going to any other page, my reputation score has of course gone back down to the pre-accept level.

Now I don't care about the checkmark or the +15 reputation; my concern here is that the OP doesn't seem to notice that they can accept only one answer. The OP just accepts each answer in turn, likely not noticing that accepting an answer past the first one un-accepts the previously accepted answer.

Does this occur often? Do many new users make this mistake?

Is it possible to have a warning/info box pop up for the OP when the OP attempts to accept a second answer on the same post within, say, 1 minute of another accept? It wouldn't affect the OP's ability to accept any answer whenever he/she wants.

Perhaps it could be worded something like this:

We're happy that you have chosen to accept an answer! But please be aware that only one answer can be accepted; accepting a second answer un-accepts the previously accepted answer. At your discretion you may accept exactly one answer that you think answers your question the best.

The link would go to the site's specific /help/someone-answers page.

This sounds relatively easy to implement and it would educate a new user in place that only one answer can be accepted, so that they will choose wisely.

What do you think? Should the message be worded differently? Tweak the "within 1 minute" time? Is this even worth it?

enter image description hereenter image description here

What? I can only have one plate?

  • I've never personally observed this happening, so I assume it's fairly rare overall. Detailed stats would be good, though. Mar 26 '16 at 2:34
  • 3
    I have had this multiple times. Good request! Mar 26 '16 at 12:01
  • @NathanTuggy I wish I could produce detailed stats. But in my first attempt to list votes on a post in SEDE I determined that there appears to be no record of unaccepts. If the OP accepts one answer, then another answer, there seems to be a record of the latest accept only. It appears that the previous accept record in the votes table is deleted. The data must exist somewhere if not in SEDE; if an unaccept occurs on a different UTC day, you can see the "unaccept / -15" in your reputation history, and you can always see the exact timestamp of when an answer was accepted.
    – rgettman
    Mar 28 '16 at 17:48

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .