Recently I found some sites that are a part of the Stack Exchange network but were not proposed. In other words, I'm talking about sites that are not established through Area51, like Super User.

Which sites are these that are part of the Stack Exchange network and have not been proposed / were not established through Area51?

  • 2
    That would be easy enough for you to work out for yourself. Any sites that existed before Stack Exchange 2.0 didn't go through area 51. So look at stackexchange.com/sites?view=list#oldest and go through them from top to bottom until you find one that was proposed through Area51. All the ones above that weren't. Then, add on any remaining sites with a custom domain (merged into SE network), and you have your list. Writing an answer now. – wizzwizz4 Sep 2 '16 at 10:36
  • 5
    Not quite right, @wizzwizz4. – Oded Sep 2 '16 at 10:42
  • 1
    @Oded I know, the Russian Language site was given a Stack Exchange URL, and the Russian Stack Overflow didn't go through Area 51. Seeing as your answer is definitive and correct, I won't write my incomplete one. – wizzwizz4 Sep 2 '16 at 10:44
  • Considering CS50 is in beta, I'd say it is indeed an a51 proposal – TrojanByAccident Jan 14 '17 at 2:50
  • @Trojan How does that follow? I think even SO had a beta stage at some point, back in the mists of time. I tried searching Area 51, and there aren't any proposals called CS50 there. – Rand al'Thor Jan 14 '17 at 2:54
  • interesting. I guess not, then. – TrojanByAccident Jan 14 '17 at 3:00

The original three (also called the trilogy) came into being before Area 51 existed:

  • Stack Overflow
  • Server Fault
  • Super User

After that, two sites that were created via the former Stack Exchange 1.0 model got fully merged into the network (the idea behind Stack Exchange 1.0 was to host sites on different topics for other people in exchange for payment - this didn't work):

  • MathOverflow
  • Sound Design

A couple of special cases are:

  • Stack Apps - which, though using the same Q&A engine, is not really a Q&A site; manually created in order to host and promote programs using the Stack Exchange API
  • Meta Stack Exchange - came into being as Meta Stack Overflow to supersede an old meta discussion site on the UserVoice platform before Area 51 existed; subsequently renamed and re-scoped, with a new per-site meta created for Stack Overflow
  • Area 51 and Area 51 Discussions, for obvious reasons
  • Ask Patents - which was created in collaboration with the U.S. Patents and Trademarks Office
  • stackexchange.com - not a Q&A site

After this - Stack Exchange purchased hashcode.ru, which was a Stack Exchange clone in Russian. Some of their sites were migrated into our network, never going through Area 51, though one of the sites was associated with an old Area 51 proposal:

  • ru.stackoverflow.com - for programmers, in Russian
  • rus.stackexchange.com - for Russian language, in Russian

There is also the following site which was created in collaboration with edX, but is not technically part of the network:

  • cs50.stackexchange.com - for those completing the CS50x edX course

Additionally, Stack Exchange runs the following sites previously operated by hashcode.ru (also known as sezn.ru), which weren't created through Area 51. These sites are entirely separate from the rest of the Stack Exchange network and operated on their own server, which nevertheless is controlled by Stack Exchange:

  • math.hashcode.ru - for mathematics help, in Russian; was large enough to be considered for importing, but community members there objected to importing the site since the rules regarding homework questions would have to be changed
  • phys.sezn.ru - for physics enthusiasts, in Russian; was supposed to be shut down as part of a mass shutdown of sezn.ru communities that were deemed too small, but kept up due to oversight from the team; was decided to retain in current form due to a small number of active users

I believe these are all of them.


Sites without an Area 51 page

Edge cases

Some sites have an Area 51 page, but nonetheless weren't really created through Area 51, as they predate their appearance on Area 51. These sites were either newly created and seeded with content from a prior SE 1.0 site; others were created outside and subsequently re-associated with existing Area 51 proposals:

  • Electrical Engineering (seeded with content from former SE 1.0 site chiphacker.com)
  • Mi Yodeya (SE 1.0 site; re-associated with "Judaism" proposal on Area 51)
  • Personal Finance & Money (seeded with content from former SE 1.0 site basicallymoney.com)
  • SharePoint (seeded with content from former SE 1.0 site SharePoint Overflow)
  • Stack Overflow in Russian (formerly hashcode.ru; the Area 51 proposal existed independently of the import, and was later connected to the already-launched site)
  • 7
    "Meta Stack Exchange (not really a Q&A site)" - hey, what d'you mean? I just posted a question here and got an answer! :-P – Rand al'Thor Jan 14 '17 at 3:19
  • @Randal'Thor MSE is a feedback site rather that Q&A site! – Pandya Oct 27 '17 at 14:01

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .