1

I recently answered a question which I had misinterpreted on my first read-through. My answer was dead wrong, and, rightfully, it was downvoted and comments were added that explained my error.

In this case, I edited my answer and commented that the answer has been fixed, however the downvote and comments remained. This leads me to the following question:

What is the correct response to obsolete comments on an incorrect answer?

  • Flag the comment as obsolete immediately
  • Flag the comment as obsolete after waiting some period of time
  • Leave the comment alone (the edit timestamp will be newer than that comment)
  • Prevent obsolete comments by deleting your incorrect answer and creating a new answer

Or is there some other more appropriate course of action

2

If there's an obsolete comment you should flag it as such immediately. There's no reason to leave around obsolete comments on a post. They're only adding noise at that point. If any of the comments are yours, you should of course just delete the comments, rather than flagging.

It's not appropriate to re-post your answer just because you want to remove a comment that is below it, even if you think that the comment is obsolete. If you do this your answer is likely to end up flagged, and the original restored.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .