38

More than once I have been in a situation when a proper response to a comment just doesn't fit within the 600 character limit & the better approach is to edit the answer.

At times like these, being able to see the comment thread would be a real benefit. When a comment addresses multiple issues, I typically find that I address part of the answer, save, compare the comment to the current state of my answer, then repeat the process until I'm done.

I can open the edit page in a new tab, but frankly I usually never think about this until I've been editing & I realize I want to reread the comment. Sometimes this happens on questions too, but less often for me & I see that question has already been asked.

6

An extra with the new inline editing feature is that comments on the post, be it question or answer, remain when you kick into the inline edit mode.

Not only are comments on the post visible, but all the comments on that page are.

There, laying in wait, ready for the editor to pluck its collective juices and squeeze some more information into an answer, or clarity into the question.

  • I've noticed that already - very nice. – Mark Ransom Jul 23 '11 at 2:37
  • 2
    Unfortunately, it's only for users with 2k rep at the moment. – Hannele Feb 7 '13 at 15:04
4
+50

I often right-click on the edit link and open it in a new tab or window. That way I can see the complete original answer, the comments, the original question, and any other answers.

3

Seeing as we now have the original question visible when editing an answer, it would be great to have the comments to the answer visible - that's usually why I am editing my own answers anyway - to provide additional context to the answer based on the OP's comments to my answer

It's not that my response might be more than 600 characters more that the response needs to be properly formatted, with more than "inline" code - the lack of support for paragraph breaks in comments means I rarely use them for responding to comments.

Edit to add

If it wasn't the case when the question was asked originally, when editing an answer now you can use the linked Question title to take you back to the original page - either Ctrl click, or right-click|Open in new window/tab.

  • @yoda, my answer presents a workaround that to me negates the need for the requested feature. Comments are hardly ever the only thing I need to refer to on the original page. – Mark Ransom Jun 30 '11 at 3:18

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .