30

I noticed on Retrocomputing that self-deleted posts do not show up in the Deleted section of the 10k Tools. Why is this? It seems like it would be useful to have all deleted posts show up in this list.

  • 2
    Self deletion is the #1 cause of deletion on SO... – Braiam Mar 18 '17 at 2:17
22

I agree. Moderators can access a list of self-deleted posts, but as a moderator I want the community to be watching over deletions, not just mods. 10k users would be able to see those posts if they had the links, and we give them a tool to review other deletions. So why not include self-deletions in the 10k deleted-posts list? I don't see a way that this can hurt, and it can help the community share the moderation work.

3

I assume Stack Exchange does not want to "shame" users.

Suppose one wrote a REALLY dumb question or answer, then realised it's bad seconds after posting, and deleted it. While it will always be there, visible to 10k users who happen to visit the question, I think it's better not to spread the shame.

So, I do agree with this behavior.


However, with some tweaks it can be made even better:

  1. If the post was self deleted X hours after being posted, do show it in the 10k tools.

    or

  2. If the post had at least one upvote when deleted, do show it in the 10k tools.

This way we can monitor possible good posts being self deleted.

  • 2
    Yes,it would be shame when 10k users see dumb post. Agree! – Fawad Mar 24 '17 at 10:23
  • 3
    In theory, 10k+ users would be the mods. Once they were called as "community moderators", differentiating them from the "diamond moderators", what we call now only mods. Unfortunately, the privilege system is inflated a little bit since then, making the 10k+ too little advancement compared to the effort required to reach it. Thus, on the original reasons, I think yes, the mods (in its original sense) should see all deletion events. – peterh Mar 25 '17 at 16:14
  • What about on Metas? I think that on metas with lower activity, any deleted post should be shown in the 10k tools. – JAL Mar 27 '17 at 18:41
  • 1
    @JAL good point about meta sites, but still, same argument holds true - people can make silly mistakes so they self delete. – Shadow The Curly Braced Wizard Mar 27 '17 at 20:23
  • But it's not like you can easily stumble across these "dumb" questions (or answers). And you only see the last 7 days by default (30 days max). When I'm looking through the deleted posts list I'm generally looking for a specific post, I'm not casually browsing. I don't really see why you would provide access to deleted posts for 10K+ users when it is going to be further moderated? (Even "trusted users" 20K+ can't see these self-deleted posts.) – MrWhite Aug 28 '18 at 12:42
  • I've seen this scenario played out a few times... user asks ambiguous question that gets several comments seeking clarification. User later deletes the question (I'm assuming) and re-asks the same question... process starts over. I'm sure I commented on the original question, but there is no record in my comment history and there is no deleted question with a similar title in the deleted posts section of the mod tools. "Eh?", I'm thinking. I can't see how the comments on the original question played out. Mods seem to have missed it as they did not see the original question. – MrWhite Aug 28 '18 at 12:52
  • @MrWhite still, my stand holds. What you describe (users re-posting questions) is abuse of the system, such users should be reported and suspended by moderators, after a warning. – Shadow The Curly Braced Wizard Aug 28 '18 at 13:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .