5

Sometimes, someone edits my posts. The edits were very helpful. So I want to thank him (or her).

How do you thank for editing?

  • 2
    Let's not do that @angussidney. I get the whole "good quality" requirement you've put in there, but in the end you're not supposed to be rewarded with upvotes because you made a good edit. I foresee users saying "well, that's has a positive score, so let me upvote that one", rather than honestly evaluating the content. – Bart Apr 21 '17 at 12:05
  • You approve it if its a lower rep user and don't roll back otherwise. Most of my edits as are things that bother me ;) – Journeyman Geek Apr 22 '17 at 2:22
9

Thanks are not expected for editing. I suspect that simply accepting them rather than rolling them back will be all that editors want.

Using the occasional comment to thank should do no great harm but I recommend not doing it often and, when you do, be specific about what you are thanking them for.

A comment that says little more than thanks has no value.

  • 1
    I agree. Thanking the editor in a comment may be okay, especially when the editor goes up and beyond doing a few grammatical corrections and genuinely improves the post, which could cost the editor more than a couple of minutes in doing so. – Ken Graham Apr 21 '17 at 11:40
5

@ notifications can also be used to ping editors. So a comment can make the editor aware of your gratefulness. As already stated, this is not the intended purpose of comments, but you can always delete the comment after a while, when you think it reached its target.

As there is no mechanism to reward outstanding edits with extra reputation, I do not consider it a problem if the editor is at least rewarded with some verbal praise in a comment. By contrast, thanking people for questions and answers is much less called for as there are mechanisms for this (votes and bounties).

An alternative to leaving a comment is checking whether the editor is active in the site’s chatrooms and contact them there.

3

There's no need to thank editors.

You can comment on the post and @reply to the editor and they will be notified, but "Thank you"s aren't what comments are meant for so don't be offended if it is flagged and removed.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .