I propose a mechanical system to call out exceptional posts.

Sometimes, you see a post that is just above and beyond the call of duty. Excellent formatting, experience based, etc.

The post that made me think of it was this one explaining paper minis in D&D, but there are plenty of examples that one could find.

There is a not-dissimilar system present in worldbuilding.se: One Year of Building Worlds
Wherein they call out a lot of great posts in the relevant meta.

Perhaps there's a small badge or rep gain (like a site-sponsored bounty, of sorts). Maybe it's just "seeing your name in the paper", so to speak.

  • Some sites do/did this type of posts already. – Nog Shine May 1 '18 at 15:53
  • @NogShine I know that some SE's do this, hence why I linked one of them. But I want something more present across the stacks. Ideally badges. – goodguy5 May 1 '18 at 15:57
  • eh, i mean... who decides what a quality post is? we can't really base it on voting alone, as many of the most upvoted posts aren't upvoted due to their immaculate quality, instead they're upvoted due to being shared on reddit/twitter and being fun/interesting. – Kevin B May 1 '18 at 18:10
  • What do you mean by "mechanical system"? An automatic rule-based system? Or like Wikipedia's featured articles? Or something else? – Peter Mortensen May 2 '18 at 13:46

Because choosing posts to honor in this way requires input from the community, this can't be automated. Except for two exceedingly-rare cases, all badge awards are automated and I don't see that changing.

Because the community needs to be involved anyway, this is an ideal thing for communities to self-organize. You linked to a one-time example; some other sites run quarterly "best answer" contests, with nominations and awards driven by the community. The winning answers are not necessarily the highest-scoring ones; sometimes they're in obscure areas that just didn't interest as many people but are nonetheless excellent. We've all seen cases where a quick low-effort answer to a popular question takes off (Hot Network Questions in particular), so this can't be score-driven. As an alternative, at least one site holds an annual bounty event.

Communities can and do self-organize to reward quality content. Instead of looking for a mechanical system-wide reward that would probably not highlight the stuff that ought to be highlighted, look around at what other communities are already doing and copy, adapt, or invent systems that work for your own community.

The two exceedingly-rare manual badges are Not a Robot, for attending (larger) events with SO Inc. presence, and a badge for discovering and correctly reporting certain security issues. I think this second one is retired now; I didn't find it on the badge list.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .