8

Should we allow ping to a user who can't talk in chat? Recently I visited a meta.SE chatroom. Even though I don't have enough rep to talk, I could still get pinged and notified. Since a user with less rep cannot reply to the ping, is it OK to notify them?

An image reference:

enter image description here

2
  • You can also ping users that are suspended, they can't respond in chat either but will get notified
    – rene
    Jun 26, 2018 at 9:31
  • So you mean it is ok to get notified when pinged ? @rene
    – Baby Be'el
    Jun 26, 2018 at 9:32

1 Answer 1

11

Should we allow pinging users who can't talk in chat?

It is kind of pointless, specially if the user you pinged isn't going to reach the chat threshold anywhere soon. But as users can join the chatroom while they can't talk yet I don't see why we would need to limit the features any further.

Since a user with less rep cannot reply to the ping, is it OK to notify them?

It depends. If the ping is aimed to be welcoming, inclusive and encouraging to have users reach the chat privilege I see no problem. If the @-mention is used to ridicule such users it definitely isn't and against the be nice policy. It is even more rude and disheartening due to the fact that the user can't respond directly. Such chat messages are subject to be flagged.

Do note that users that are chat banned can also join a chatroom and be pinged without being able to talk.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .