Where the goal of closing a question is to revise and re-open
Proposal: Include form for user that votes to close as "unclear" to clarify what is "unclear" and when edits clarify
- Vote to close "unclear what you're asking"
1) Mandatory field(s): Specify precisely what is "unclear" to you in the question
- Question is now clear -> vote towards re-opening
- Question is not clear, refer to field N
User is reminded of "unclear what you're asking" queue for votes cast.
The same approach can be used for "off-topic" and "too broad" selected reasons for vote to close a question.
Solves: Avoidance of guessing what the vote to close as "unclear" is actually referring to by that user and provides a means to address specific issues as interpreted by that specific user.
The purpose of the feature is to be inclusive as possible as to the range of possible questions from different perspectives, and to address the specific issues with the question openly to improve the question for eventual re-opening.