4

This is sort of similar to Let reviewers know if a suggested edit will push the question into the reopen queue, which was positively received, but was declined for technical reasons.

I propose that users who are editing a post that was closed within the last five days be shown a notice on top of the edit form indicating that the post will be added to the reopen queue if edited, and that if one does not plan on editing the post into a state where it can be reopened, one should wait until five days after closure to make the edit.

Closed questions are only added to the review queue once per closure by editing, and if a user comes by and makes a minor (yet benign) edit, the diff that reopen reviewers see is just that of the minor edit, and as such they dismiss the task as "Leave Closed", which prevents it from being added to the queue again by another edit. This deprives the post author (and others interested in seeing the question reopened) of their chance to get the post reopened by editing.

Here on Meta, I've noticed that a certain user (name redacted) prolifically makes grammar edits to posts closed within five days, depriving the post of the chance to be reopened by editing as those edits don't edit the question into a reopenable state. I understand that the user may be using an automated tool to do these edits, but this will be a big help because 99%+ of users make edits solely manually.

To help make this request more technically feasible, I propose that it instead only be loaded with the edit form, and that it should only be shown to users who can make binding edits. (Suggested edits occur at the time of approval, and the request to let the reviewers know has already been declined.)

Here's an example of what I'm expecting:

This question was [put on hold/marked as duplicate] within the last 5 days.

This question will be added to a queue for possible reopening if you make this edit. If you are not planning to edit this post into a state where it can be reopened, please wait until [date and time] to make your edit.

If you are only making edits to the question's tags, please ignore this notice.

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .