12

This just happened. I was editing a comment to add some additional text. When I was finished, two comments resulted, with the edited comment appearing above the unedited version.

The timestamp tooltip on the upper, longer, edited version is 04:43:15Z whereas the timestamp on the lower, shorter, unedited one is later at 04:43:38!

I'm not sure if this rises to the level of a meta question, but I don't know of a separate potential bug-reporting method.

Comments in question (the last two in the screenshot) are on this answer. Click for larger view.

screenshot of space.stackexchange /a/30287/12102

Update, Feb 28, 2019: It just happened again here, internet was indeed "flaky" at the time:

Update, Mar 4, 2019: It just happened again, again here, and yes, connection was "flaky" again. The term comes from comments, my connection here is very slow at the moment.

Update, Mar 7, 2019: It just happened again, again here

Update, Mar 9, 2019: It just happened again, again here when comment first posted (no editing)

Update, Mar 11, 2019: It just happened again, again here

Update, Mar 16, 2019: It just happened again, again here

Update, Mar 18, 2019: It just happened again, again here

enter image description here

Update, Mar 27, 2019: It just happened again, again here in chat I was given the option to Retry and clicked it.

enter image description here

**I'm not going to continue to post events that are similar, and I'll instead make a note if it stops happening.

  • 2
    You can report bugs on any Meta site, so this question is fine. – rene Aug 26 '18 at 7:10
  • 3
    Could it be that your network connection was flaky at the time? That is the only situation I've seen before that causes these kind of weird things. – rene Aug 26 '18 at 7:11
  • All edits on above comments worked for me without any issues. So no repro for now in Chrome/Win10 – rene Aug 26 '18 at 7:13
  • @rene I don't have "flaky detection" software installed right now, but at the time I was using a shared WiFi router sitting on a water heater in a hallway that occasionally stops cooperating. My MacOS WiFi debugging feature then reports several problems when that happens. While that didn't happen today, the connection is in general therefore less than ideal. I've also had this and also this have happen in the past, from the same location. – uhoh Aug 26 '18 at 7:23
  • Get a better server/connection/card? If this is a problem at your end, someone mentioned a "flaky" connection, I don't see what SE can do for you and I don't see how updating your problem is helpful. Maybe try the solutions offered here lifehacker.com/… – Mari-Lou A Mar 18 at 11:57
  • @Mari-LouA It's not "what SE can do for you", it's what I can do for SE. What I can do is report unusual behavior and make a small collection of instances in case it is helpful for analysis. I have no idea of the cause, if on this end could be neighborhood or ISP. If SE decides they are not interested in this information, someone will tell me. – uhoh Mar 18 at 12:25
  • But if the problem is at your end, and you haven't denied this possibility, why not perform checks and confirm it or see if you can fix it. See if it's a problem of software, platform or if it's a question of poor internet connection. There must be ways of finding this out other than seeing comments being duplicated. – Mari-Lou A Mar 18 at 13:03
  • You've also said and yes, connection was "flaky" again. I mean, I lose Internet connection every day, every single day, which that means I can't upload comments, I lose posts, I can't refresh etc . That doesn't mean I post on Meta reporting every instance my Internet (or my mac, I still haven't figured out who's to blame) falters or stops. P.S I actually posted a link. P.P.S "at your end" does not mean it's your fault. – Mari-Lou A Mar 18 at 13:09
  • @Mari-LouA rather than a series of comments, maybe you or someone else can add an answer explaining how I can check if these double-comments are caused at my end. If it's something reasonable that can provide useful information, I'll give it a try. But I think generating a dialogue suggesting without evidence that it's my fault could be distracting. Let's keep the focus on the site's behavior. – uhoh Mar 18 at 13:10
  • 1
    You're definitely sending multiple requests to the system which is what is causing the duplicate comments. Nothing in our code auto-retries submitting something if the request failed. Perhaps your system is doing something to retry a request it thinks failed because it got no response in time? What OS and browser are you using? Are you not getting any sort of error message in between the first comment submission and the second one? If you ever get the chance to see the console / network requests info in the browser's dev tools after this situation, it'd probably be really helpful. – animuson Mar 28 at 6:42
  • @animuson MacOS and Chrome. I'm not a developer but if you can describe what I should look at/for (or point me at something I can read) I can keep an eye out and make a screen shot like i.stack.imgur.com/6FVMz.png or grab text or save something. Thanks! – uhoh Mar 28 at 7:12
  • @animuson I've just had this happen again twice from a Starbucks WiFi i.stack.imgur.com/4dvUq.png links: 1, 2 no error messages, it just looks the same as it does when there's a few second delay during normal "busy WiFi " activity. (fyi this is probably unrelated) – uhoh May 28 at 3:29
  • @animuson other Starbucks instance was here. – uhoh May 28 at 3:41

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .