4

I have been receiving several unupvotes on my answers systematically.

The unupvotes appear to be targeting my answers that have garnered more than two or three votes.

These unupvotes seem to be spaced over a week, the latest series being three unupvotes today:

screenshot of reputation history showing three upupvotes today

I casually chatted in RE.SE chat some time back about the issue, and there it was suggested that I raise the issue here. (Quoting the relevant suggestion from RE.SE CHAT.)

still, a question that was not modified/edited for a while has it's vote lock on and therefore users cannot just retract their upvote. Either a user was removed causing all of her upvotes being removed? or something funky happened. Regardless, I cannot think of anything @IgorSkochinsky can do about it. Instead, you may wanna open a question over at meta.stackexchange.com, explicitly focusing on vote-locked posts.

Is something funky happening or are they genuine unupvotes made by someone who feels those answers don't merit their upvotes?

Based on the comments and an answer that was received, it appears vote lock is broken when an edit is done by anyone including a bot run by SO.

If so, doesn't such breaks have a time limit for relocking?
Do they remain open for years together?
Could this behavior be treated as a bug?

Update

Just an update and some queries which are based on certain comments and answers:

I received two more unupvotes today

enter image description here

  • again an old post
  • again edited but this time the edit was by myself
  • and the edits took place within 3 hours of my initial answer 3 years ago as per edit history

enter image description here

I'm not sure if my answer received a vote within these three hours which was unupvoted - if not, then the vote must have come in after the edit and unupvoted today or it was never voted in first place, but I still lose 10 points.

Is there a possibility to get some hints as to what happened or is happening?

  • 3
    This is clearly abuse (targeting the person, not the posts), and the RE.SE mods should escalate it to the Stack Exchange Community team to punish the infractor. – Jeremy Banks Sep 3 '18 at 22:26
  • I did a searched for a Q&A on meta about the CU unlocking votes and found nothing, only two circumstances under which it would unlock posts. It seems that even if the bot is bumping it shouldn't reset other attributes. You might consider adding the feature-request / bug tag to your question to have this issue corrected. --- It certainly is annoying to lose some points for no apparent reason, especially when two of those answers were accepted, but since they aren't downvotes I don't think they will be reversed. – Rob Sep 4 '18 at 1:08
  • Many of your new subquestions are answered here: meta.stackexchange.com/questions/160876/… – Sonic the Reinstate Monica-hog Sep 5 '18 at 22:08
  • Actually, considering the answer you already have, it's unlikely that a staff member would look into this. I've filed a bug report based on the answer here, so the bug tag is unnecessary here. – Sonic the Reinstate Monica-hog Sep 5 '18 at 22:25
  • My bug report has been negatively received, with the top answer saying that if a user abuses automatic edits to unupvote a particular user, that user should be dealt with. I suggest contacting SE regarding this. – Sonic the Reinstate Monica-hog Sep 9 '18 at 6:28
  • @SonictheInclusiveHedgehog yes i read the thread and the answers already i am not sure if it is a single user abusing a single target the latest unupvotes seems to be contradicting as far as i see (not sure if i see right ) – blabb Sep 9 '18 at 6:42
8

Taking your answer to Disassemble instruction with a variable as an offset as an example:

If the initial upvote came before the Community edit then the vote will have been unlocked by that edit. The user is then free to remove that vote (or convert it into a down-vote) at any point from then.

As to why they chose now to do so, I've no idea.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .