2

I have a question about comparing "Classical internet routing vs. Swarm intelligence routing (such as ACO)" as follows:

Here is my question:

Is it possible to mention the drawbacks/advantages of Swarm routing (such as Ant routing etc) in comparison with classical routing algorithms in communication networks in a general view?

In other words, what will we gain if we replace a classical routing algorithm with a swarm routing based algorithm?

Can we compare these two type of routing algorithms in a general view to mention their to count the drawbacks/advantages? The main purpose of this question is to define applications of each of those routing approaches. Which one is more decentralized? And which one has more efficient performance?

Here is my personal opinion (I am not sure about it) :

classical internet routing in more centralized than swarm routing (such as ACO based routing) which does not use any routing table and router to avoid moving towards centralization where those routing tables and routers can be manipulated (as a point of failure). Instead, classical internet routing may be faster than swarm based routing. Briefly, classical may be more centralized, but faster and on the other side, swarm based is more decentralized but may be slower. So, cannot we conclude that Swarm based routing is more appropriate for decentralized networks? Am I wrong?

So, we now can ask that : Which approach is more decentralized? And Which one is faster?

Please note that networkengineering.stackexchange.com says this question is off-topic for networkengineeringstack Exchange.

Thanks

  • 2
    This sounds pretty opinionated, more than an actual objective question. – fbueckert Dec 13 '18 at 15:54
  • Yes, the question is multidisciplinary between networking, distributed systems , artificial intelligence. – sas Dec 13 '18 at 15:56
  • 2
    I'm not saying it's multidisciplinary. I'm saying there's likely not a real objective answer. Along with it likely being rather broad. If Network Engineering wouldn't take it, then I'm not sure where else you might ask this. There may not be be anywhere on the network where this would be acceptable. – fbueckert Dec 13 '18 at 16:03
  • Problem is that Network Engineering prefers more "business" based questions (as they said) that is more centralized networking; however, Swarm based routing could be more suitable for ad hoc networks that are very decentralized. But Network Engineering believes that ad hoc network is not normally used in business. In the next comment, I bring out two comments from Networking Engineering. – sas Dec 13 '18 at 16:13
  • (1) "Ad hoc networks are not normally used in a business because of the lack of control. Businesses use infrastructure mode for Wi-Fi and centralized control." AND (2) "Network Engineering Stack Exchange is for asking questions about professionally managed networks in a business environment." (by user Ron Maupin.) Thanks – sas Dec 13 '18 at 16:14
  • I'm not sure how that's strengthening your question. Yes, NE.SE won't take it. Those comments just highlight how opinionated the question is. – fbueckert Dec 13 '18 at 16:19
  • Do I need to modify it? (with keeping the main context of question: i.e. which approach is more decentralized? And which one is faster?) – sas Dec 13 '18 at 16:23
  • I don't think your question as it stands would fit on any site; you're highlighting why it's problematic. The main context (especially the fast aspect) depends on lots of variables that are likely weighted differently for each reader. Can you distill it into a specific, objective, focused question? – fbueckert Dec 13 '18 at 16:30
  • In fact, I added the last section to question by asking "Which approach is more decentralized? And Which one is faster?" that can shows the target of question: i.e. which approach is more appropriate for more decentralized networks? however, the remained problem is that one approach (swarm based routing) is more related to artificial intelligence and other one (classical routing) is related to classical networking. – sas Dec 13 '18 at 16:36
  • 1

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .