6

The Help Center article on duplicates contains the following statement:

The original question must have an answer; you cannot mark a question as a duplicate of an unanswered one.

Screenshot of Help Center article

While this is generally true, moderators can close questions as duplicates even if the original question does not have any answers.

Can the statement be modified to reflect this?

  • 2
    Also that sentence should be omitted entirely on this site's help center, as here on MSE normal users can close questions as duplicates of unanswered ones. – Sonic the Wizard Werehog Feb 1 at 3:11
12

How 'bout this:

The original question generally must have an answer; questions may only be marked as duplicates of unanswered questions on meta sites, when the questions share the same author, or when closed by a moderator.

  • Perfect. And quick. – Alex Feb 1 at 3:40
  • Quick grammar issue: "on meta sites, when the questions share the same author" may imply an AND relationship instead of an OR relationship. I suggest listing meta sites as the last item in the list. – Sonic the Wizard Werehog Feb 1 at 3:45
  • Also, questions that have answers but no positive-scoring or accepted answer can't be used as duplicate targets either (on main sites). – Sonic the Wizard Werehog Feb 1 at 3:47
  • Should there be something to clarify whether the distinction of a question that was answered in the comments but has no Answers versus a question that was edited by the poster to contain the answer within the question versus no answer at all? Because it seems to me like it should be possible to mark something a duplicate of the first two of those even without a special case. But I'm new here, so I really don't know how it works, and I know that some people will argue anything if it's not spelled out. – Ed Grimm Feb 1 at 7:05
  • @EdGrimm "answer" refers to the type of post. – Sonic the Wizard Werehog Feb 1 at 7:20
  • Considering the number of questions I've seen that have the explanation in the form of a comment, that choice sounds unwise. But it is at least good to understand what that choice is. – Ed Grimm Feb 1 at 22:49
  • 2
    @SonictheIntrovertedHedgehog: In a comma-separated list, the conjunction at the end of the list ("or" in this case) distributes over the whole list. That's just English grammar, no need to clarify it. If Shog had not used an Oxford comma, I might agree with you, however. – Kevin Feb 2 at 12:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .