-10

What if we had some sort of warning that users' questions seem off-topic, especially on MSE? It seems to me that a large majority of the blatantly off-topic questions here should be on Stack Overflow. It could work like this:

  • It's got a list of keywords, sort of like Smoke Detector but for programming.
    • Maybe programming language names and terms, such as "Ruby" and "Python" and "if statement".
  • It looks for if there are large codeblocks with a lot of what appears to be syntax.
  • It disables if the user has more than 10 reputation or so on Meta.
  • It runs when the "Post Your Question" button is pressed.
    • If the keyword condition or the codeblock condition is met and it is enabled, it displays some sort of thing like a box popping out of the posting button that has a message like "Are you sure this question is on-topic? This appears to be about programming. For questions about programming, go to Stack Overflow".

Ironic how it would trigger on this post if I had less reputation...

  • 2
    It's pretty common for people to be quoting, paraphrasing, or otherwise discussing the content of programming questions, so lots of appropriate meta questions have all of those things. – Servy May 7 at 14:23
  • 2
    Programming is only one part of off-topic questions; we also get off-topic questions that run the gamut of SE sites. – fbueckert May 7 at 14:25
  • 1
    @Servy this wouldn’t stop them from posting; it would just notify them that they’re on Meta, not SO and they could still post it if it were actually on-topic. – Stormblessed May 7 at 14:48
  • 1
    @fbueckery this could include those too, the description in the post is only about programming just because that’s a lot more narrow and it could trigger on many of the off-topic questions. – Stormblessed May 7 at 14:48
  • 1
    It's still a pretty wide net you'd be trying to cast. Not sure how useful it would be to even make, with the potential issue of false positives. – fbueckert May 7 at 15:00
  • I propose a banner ... – rene May 7 at 15:34
  • Simply roll a dice with 1s and 0s on it. If it lands on a 1, then mark the question off topic. It'll be right 50% of the time here. – Won't May 7 at 16:28
8

Like Servy says, many valid questions about code would cause false positives to such a detector and needlessly complicate posting them. And users come here with their mathematics and general software/hardware problems too.

I feel a modified Ask Question Wizard would be much more effective in discouraging users from posting blatantly off-topic questions, but some people are just too desperate for answers and will still post here.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .