Currently, when attempting to answer questions with lots of answers (usually 30 but configurable per site), users are shown the following generic JS confirmation prompt (from one's browser, in this case Edge):

JS confirmation prompt warning of 30+ answers

In my opinion, this looks rather drab, and in many cases users just skip the prompt without bothering to read it. It also doesn't fit well with SE's design goals. Finally, if users' browsers are configured to automatically skip past these prompts (which is what happens if the checkbox depicted on the bottom above is checked), users will never see this prompt.

To help align better with SE's latest design goals, and to try and reduce the numbers of users whose eyes gloss past, muscle memories skip, or browsers automatically bypass generic warning messages, I'd like to propose that it be replaced with a Stacks design popup like the following:

Styled popup prompting the same thing

I'd also like to take the opportunity to propose a couple wording changes: first, the prompt is shown upon [x]+ answers, not >[x] answers, so on a question with exactly 30 answers (on most sites) the current warning message says "more than 30 answers" which is incorrect. Second, this prompt is also shown to anonymous (logged-out) users, who see an "improve this answer" link instead of "edit", so if the user is logged out the dialog should change to say "'improve this answer' link".

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .